The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Optimize]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83941132&userid=948039&signature=AnH12jmeANeRLzp5l0DiAQ

could someone please help me with this? Thanks so much

Without the '17 rare it would be fair - 2019 store pets come to about a mid-2010 rare, combined with the other 2010 rare would make it 2 '09 rares, which I personally would say is equivalent to an '09 VR. VRs can be tricky though, I'd get another opinion!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83941132&userid=948039&signature=AnH12jmeANeRLzp5l0DiAQ

could someone please help me with this? Thanks so much

Slightly unfair to you -- just your Malk Cat, dog and store pet would be about fair. The 2017 rare is unnecessary.

Thank you so much guys!

[Xiao_Jian]

Hello, friends! Could someone tell me if this was fair? I’m just curious, as I’m happy with the trade either way.

technically speaking the cerberus is only worth 505 c$. i guess it's high on the demand list, but i personally think you overpaid..

Thank you for the response amidst all this chaos! I tried trading with multiple users but none if them were interested, so demand wise, would this still have been overpay on my side?

Well, this the C$ worth thread speculates the Orange Cerb could go for 2K+. So you decide.
Forum/search.php?keywords=cerb&t=3915876&sf=msgonly

[Free Shade]

Can I get some help with this?
I'm bad at adding up large quantities of non-list pets and could use some help ;u;
For my UR Tiger

It's 223 pets and 816 items (large trade sorry ;n;).
I've been able to spot a Blue Balloon, an OMSR rat, a handful of advents, and a ton of the new store pets (that I already have 2 sets of), and the items which seem to be a mix of newer and older.

Would like to know roughly what their side adds up to?
(with or without the items)

[MidnightDuchess]

Fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83911991&userid=845505&signature=BDXW5kUWx-B1zvcmSF3vMw

[Foxed]

is this a fair trade? i'm not very good with items!

*edit
and this one?? i know i have some older items in there, but not too sure about demand! especially on the mermaid tails?

[Niragi]

Hello, friends! Could someone tell me if this was fair? I’m just curious, as I’m happy with the trade either way.

Well, this the C$ worth thread speculates the Orange Cerb could go for 2K+. So you decide.
Forum/search.php?keywords=cerb&t=3915876&sf=msgonly

Personally I’ve seen the red cerb being traded for 4K and 4.5k C$ before which equals to its demand non worth (3.5-4) + 0.5k, considering the Orange cerb goes for about 7-8 nons that would add up to anything between 7-8.5k C$ I’d say (1k C$ per non, even though that way of calculating worth is questionable as even the ur tiger was only put at 1840C$~)



What is this pet worth in C$? Thread
And finally, a sunjewel is worth 5 nondogs. 264,600C$ or $13,926 USD.
This is why we simply cannot use rarity math like this. A sunjewel right now, at 1840C$, is worth $105 USD which is still a lot of money, but clearly a lot more doable than nearly 14k.



I’d personally say even 7-8k C$ would have been a huge amount of overpay, you paid twice that worth. However, it’s difficult to find someone willing to part with their Orange cerb for valuable pets nowadays, so a pure C$ trade seems even more unlikely. It’s up to you if you’re happy with the trade or not ultimately, 15k C$ equals around 800 USD after all.

[write]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83954782&userid=631934&signature=aJi7TnQm5omQvtNFGuMlrQ
Would this be fair? I'm really not good with item values so don't really know how to appraise it myself. Thank you in advance!

[Kadmos]

is this a fair trade? i'm not very good with items!

*edit
and this one?? i know i have some older items in there, but not too sure about demand! especially on the mermaid tails?

Personally i think this is unfair to you, that cowboy pss costume is from 2011 Haloween. From what i heard Haloween costumes can go from a 2011 uncommon to a rare and despite that the other items are small- flower details theyr pets are common and very commons from 2018 so definetely unfair to you because they wouldnt add up together for that items itself.

Please also seek one more opinion ^^

[nyctophilia]

Can someone please tell me their opinion of this trade and what each pet on my side would be worth if individually priced? Thanks

[avaloafe]

is this fair? i know it's worth 680, but has it gone for anything higher? i'm saving it for a myo for a species and they only want the lowest price of it but if it goes for higher i'd like to know...