The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[~Misty]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955153&userid=900414&signature=GfIuCTHjGRbdKhCNyesuQQ

Would this be fair? Haven't seen anyone else with that item.

( warning, a lot of bulk, if ur computer is old, have mercy)

The item being requested is from January 2014. I Personally wouldn't offer so much for it. A common/ uncommon pet from the same year at most.

Please cancel that trade e.o
The bucket really is not worth more than an old uncommon!! You're overpaying by HEAPS!

[MidnightDuchess]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955153&userid=900414&signature=GfIuCTHjGRbdKhCNyesuQQ

Would this be fair? Haven't seen anyone else with that item.

( warning, a lot of bulk, if ur computer is old, have mercy)

The item being requested is from January 2014. I Personally wouldn't offer so much for it. A common/ uncommon pet from the same year at most.

Please cancel that trade e.o
The bucket really is not worth more than an old uncommon!! You're overpaying by HEAPS!

I legit just sent them this trade because I had the bucket and the other two I hope they cancel that one before its accepted holy cow the bucket is not worth that much at all. its legit from 2014 January and maybe worth a common from 2014 at most
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955220&userid=845505&signature=ZXqHz_rMjPye14stoTf-og

[Draconica2014]

Hi! Is this trade fair? Thanks for any help!

[Drink]

Okay, so they added three more, was this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955299&userid=900414&signature=So9q4RJZV7sX9EKz0rje9w

[Mina Ashido]

Okay, so they added three more, was this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955299&userid=900414&signature=So9q4RJZV7sX9EKz0rje9w

No, the 4 buckets are a least worth a non

[SeaCrest]

Could I get some help on this, please?

They are overpaying. Your side is worth roughly 7 09 rares. Theirs is worth about twice that amount.

Could I get a second opinion please? Thank you so much!

Nvm they cancelled~

[shiny furret]

Okay, so they added three more, was this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955299&userid=900414&signature=So9q4RJZV7sX9EKz0rje9w

you overpaid too much!

[Kadmos]

Okay, so they added three more, was this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955299&userid=900414&signature=So9q4RJZV7sX9EKz0rje9w

No not at all, this is a huge overpay! I dont understand though..Midnightduchess gave you the same items and only asked the staff pets and you decided to trade with the other person despite that everyone adviced you otherwise?

[~Misty]

Okay, so they added three more, was this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955299&userid=900414&signature=So9q4RJZV7sX9EKz0rje9w

No, the 4 buckets are a least worth a non

Sorry, where is your evidence?
They're a free item from January 2014. Legit worth an uncommon or recent rare.

[Mina Ashido]

Okay, so they added three more, was this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83955299&userid=900414&signature=So9q4RJZV7sX9EKz0rje9w

No, the 4 buckets are a least worth a non

Sorry, where is your evidence?
They're from January 2014. Legit worth an uncommon or recent rare.

It's a mega rare bucket, barely people have it.