The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jinbad]

I know I had a similar trade sent to me a while ago, but after having the Coontail for a while, I'm beginning to want to try to cut my losses.

Would this be worth it? How easy is it to trade a UR Foal for 1.5 nons, or would I struggle as much as I am with trading this Coontail for the same amount? I know the foal goes for 1 non as well, but how much more compared to 1.5? I'd love to hear some advice on this. Thank you!

foals don't have the best demand so i think they usually end up being used as fillers in larger trades (correct me if i'm wrong) and you might struggle to get 1.5 nons' worth on its own. coontails are valued at a solid 2 nons across the board from what i can tell so if you have the patience to wait around for a while more you should be able to get two nons' worth. that said, with the insane demand for store pets at the moment a lot of people are putting their higher value trading fodder more towards those and less towards the traditional list pets, so it might be a while before you actually manage to trade your boi for his true worth.

Thank you!

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83939683&userid=711966&signature=-1hEOM4u8p-NTy_56l-7LA

is this fair rarity and demand wise? its quite urgent

Help ;;v;;

Still need help rarity and demand wise qwq

the card dogs and warriors are very popular at the moment so demand wise i'd say that's good overpay on their side. the tess horses had an extended-release so they're really only worth around 2 '09 rares, and neither of the other pets on your side have any specific demand, bringing your side to around 4 '09 rares or a tier 1 advent. i'd gauge their side at 5.5-6 '09 rares.

[cheesecake.]

Hi! Please could I get some opinions on this trade?

And this one too please :)

[Falco]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83941030&userid=841851&signature=g9ldHV_-bwe4n_e_75RHjg
What should I add? Demand and rarity please !

[ThunderCedar]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83941030&userid=841851&signature=g9ldHV_-bwe4n_e_75RHjg
What should I add? Demand and rarity please !

I don't think you need to add anything. Your side has both good demand and high rarity. This seems reasonable for the dragon pps.

[maleficent.]

Could I get a second opinion on this? Thank you

[amarok.]

Hi! Please could I get some opinions on this trade?

And this one too please

the first one is very unfair to you. their side is worth just over 2 '09 rares whereas your side has an old tier five advent and is therefore worth 6.5-7.5 '09 rares.

the second one is technically overpay (by 2 '09 rares) on their side but i'd personally keep my zebras over the pets they're offering. rainbow drafts are honestly a real pain to trade away for their technical value.

[HoneyLavender࿐]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83940684&userid=869663&signature=QZGU0VlQwh1MekOE2qoBrw

[ThunderCedar]

Could I get a second opinion on this? Thank you

Looks unfair to you. I don't think their side adds up to an omgsr of any sort. The only pets that are really valuable are the Holly fox cat, the string tess horse, and the grinner.
Altogether I would say their side is worth a red rose dog at best.

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83941030&userid=841851&signature=g9ldHV_-bwe4n_e_75RHjg
What should I add? Demand and rarity please !

I don't think you need to add anything. Your side has both good demand and high rarity. This seems reasonable for the dragon pps.

i'm going to have to disagree here demand wise, though rarity wise i'd say even this is fairly daft overpay.
unfortunately pps dragon bois aren't going for a reasonable value, so you'll almost certainly be asked to add. i believe they're going for lowmainlists fairly steadily at the moment (and even a sorb isn't unheard of) and the keyword searches i've run on most of the pet value threads would back that up. it's absolutely insane. overall, i wouldn't have accepted if i was on the other side.