The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[greenbunny1998]

Is this trade fair for my card dogs?

[kkspecial4]

Is this trade fair for my card dogs?

Fairness depends on how you value the Ex-Advent List Bunny

If you still follow the now discontinued rares list:

Top side adds up to a little over 7.5-8.5 2009 Rares + 1 2009 Uncommon
(Dog Tag Bun = 6-7 2009 Rares + 1 2009 Uncommon)

Bottom side adds up to 5 2009 Rares
(2008 Very Rare = 2 2009 Rares + 1 2010 Rare)

If you no longer follow the discontinued rares list:

Top side adds up to a little over 3.5 2009 Rares
(Dog Tag Bun = 2009 Very Rare = 2 2009 Rares)

Bottom side adds up to 5 2009 Rares
(2008 Very Rare = 2 2009 Rares + 1 2010 Rare)

Demand is up to you to decide on - as is presence of pets offered or the pets you have

[maleficent.]

fair? I know the grinner and the Tess horse aren’t that good in demand, but I also know that the rat isn’t either. If unfair, what is it that would need to be added to make it a bit more fair? Thank you

[jinbad]

I know I had a similar trade sent to me a while ago, but after having the Coontail for a while, I'm beginning to want to try to cut my losses.

Would this be worth it? How easy is it to trade a UR Foal for 1.5 nons, or would I struggle as much as I am with trading this Coontail for the same amount? I know the foal goes for 1 non as well, but how much more compared to 1.5? I'd love to hear some advice on this. Thank you!

[quisicorazon]

Could I please get some help with this trade?

Would this be fair? Or would it be necessary to add more?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83909748&userid=686260&signature=0GsuaM8mXHF1d0caP-l4xA

[Doberman Pinscher]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83927067&userid=169112&signature=cMob_YIzT0XeDjPtrNELcA

How is this looking? I want it to be fair for both of us
Any help or feedback is appreciated <3

[screamingrainfrog]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83930027&userid=918338&signature=U2r84O9gE8_dC_Brbd32oA

Hi, is this fair? :'>

[The Lady Amalthea]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83931138&userid=938809&signature=d628Mt7M-JSQz1skcGJTWA
Help please

[Redpanda]

Could I get some opinions on this?

This as well, I’ve been searching for the PPS Dragon for awhile now. Not sure what it goes for.

First is very unfair to them.
Second is very unfair to you.

Ahhh could you/someone explain how it is unfair? Thank you!

[JJdiner]

Could I get some opinions on this?

This as well, I’ve been searching for the PPS Dragon for awhile now. Not sure what it goes for.

First is very unfair to them.
Second is very unfair to you.

Ahhh could you/someone explain how it is unfair? Thank you!

i think it depends on how you value your liontail and the pps dragon, i personally value my liontails as 3 nons as i have seen many trades of 3nons for them, however i think the general concensis is 2 non, so technically the cat is worth 3 nons plus, so it is unfair to them rarity, however last ive seen the cats go for mayb 2 nons, so it jsut depends on how you value it, for the dragon, i would take it, i personally value it at 2, but it goes for 1-2 (mainly 1.5)