The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ferretjuice]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83905744&userid=327768&signature=os3Vv_OLVS_-jHm39w1kWg
how is this trade? thank you!

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83905963&userid=72699&signature=aX1aPcxPPUevJAnnLVidkg
Hi everyone! Would this trade be ok? Please let me know ^^

[.Wolfskralle.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83905963&userid=72699&signature=aX1aPcxPPUevJAnnLVidkg
Hi everyone! Would this trade be ok? Please let me know ^^

Unfair to them, the store lions alone would be fair and at least one of the very rare ponies is a late '09 very rare meaning it too would be fair for the butterfly wolf.

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83905744&userid=327768&signature=os3Vv_OLVS_-jHm39w1kWg
how is this trade? thank you!

Personally wouldn't take it. As far as I know, the moonswirl still trades for 3+ nons whereas, if we value the Ur Holly at 1-1.5 and the RBM at roughly a non, they're offerin 2-2.5 nons since the rest of the pets aren't enough to bridge the gap.

[AmeKitsune]

Which trade is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83905922&userid=803513&signature=GVUPOGihNDab8zvqry8rRA

or

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83906310&userid=803513&signature=A0899Vpne-ZiMvM0Y7irCA

[skyline]

Which trade is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83905922&userid=803513&signature=GVUPOGihNDab8zvqry8rRA

or

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83906310&userid=803513&signature=A0899Vpne-ZiMvM0Y7irCA

trade 1;
the august pps's demand fluctuates decently between users, though, most people value theirs at a low (ex) main, or higher. using this guide, the c$ they're offering would add up to a tier 1 (ex) september value. though, these values were added during the time the list was around, so it's likely they're outdated.

it's also good to keep in mind that c$ is very low demand when it comes to high demand pets, not many people want it for ex lists, and general high demand pets. as for the pets they've added to the trade, they're mostly recent, and don't add too much value to the trade given the pet they're offering for.

trade 2;
the pets they're offering add up to a mid (ex) advent. i believe you could get a much better offer, i wouldn't accept either of these trades.

[GreenteaLatte]

Which trade is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83905922&userid=803513&signature=GVUPOGihNDab8zvqry8rRA

or

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83906310&userid=803513&signature=A0899Vpne-ZiMvM0Y7irCA

trade 1;
the august pps's demand fluctuates decently between users, though, most people value theirs at a low (ex) main, or higher. using this guide, the c$ they're offering would add up to a tier 1 (ex) september value. though, these values were added during the time the list was around, so it's likely they're outdated.

it's also good to keep in mind that c$ is very low demand when it comes to high demand pets, not many people want it for ex lists, and general high demand pets. as for the pets they've added to the trade, they're mostly recent, and don't add too much value to the trade given the pet they're offering for.

trade 2;
the pets they're offering add up to another low (ex) advent. i believe you could get a much better offer, i wouldn't accept either of these trades.

I'd disagree. I've never seen August pps go for mainlists. They go for around mid to high advent lists and maybe a September list if you push it.
By rarity wise, both are overpaying. First trade is worth around a low September list and the second one is worth around a high advent list.

[Donnerklang]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83887619&userid=826487&signature=U0I584NqwOWMi2WFK1YlJA

Is this fair? I'm really unsure about the worth of items.

[QueenPebbles93]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83906478&userid=947682&signature=iEe1gybnwFdw1ISQgLiz1Q

Please help!

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83906478&userid=947682&signature=iEe1gybnwFdw1ISQgLiz1Q

Please help!

That's very approximately fair for where it was originally on the list, but I'm not sure if I'd take it personally since Tess horses can be a pain to trade off sometimes. It boils down to whether you'd rather have the pet or the c$.