The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[niixyx]

Is this fair? Looking for an opinion on both demand-wise and rarity-wise
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83757830&userid=805432&signature=vUHun_AZXRN0ASXkJPvE9g

[Redpanda]

Would there side be something to consider for a coontail + moonswirl? (ignore the rest on my side)

also Would 33ish advent store pets + a september list = UR Flower pot?

Personally, I would say no

A non = about 1200 C$ by most accounts

And a moonswirl is about 3-4 nons.

I mean, some people value it at 1800 C$ but the c$ guides are Kind of trash tbh so,, I’d value your moonswirl at about 3000-5000 C$, considering what a non goes for.

Idk about that bulk tho, + the UR dog. That could have some value but I seriously doubt you’d get another moonswirl and coontail from it

Get another opinion

Thank you for the input - could i get any second opinions?

[cosmic~queen]

Hi there, is this a fair trade???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83748310&userid=964650&signature=oPWY8AuPRXUSxGacQ1_ZMQ

Not including the two unknown rarity pets, this is unfair to you. Their side adds up to just under 3 2015 rares; your side is just under 9 2015 rares. Since the unknown rarity pets are 2019 pets and unlikely to be more than uncommon, they don't make much of a difference.

Thank you!!! can I get a second opinion(just to make sure) and is there anyway to make it fair for me? like, how much is cat and squid on their own?

Looking for a second opinion before I just cancel the trade

[iago.]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83759607&userid=964094&signature=xm2iGUgQowidd4s2rdU_eA

Which one is better for my patchwork?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83758052&userid=964094&signature=LqkrG119BZ-lVLKuY-DDLw


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83757671&userid=964094&signature=ZGzf-nrwnfvUbitvhaHMsg

Thank you!

Need an answer!

[amarok.]

Hi there, is this a fair trade???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83748310&userid=964650&signature=oPWY8AuPRXUSxGacQ1_ZMQ

Not including the two unknown rarity pets, this is unfair to you. Their side adds up to just under 3 2015 rares; your side is just under 9 2015 rares. Since the unknown rarity pets are 2019 pets and unlikely to be more than uncommon, they don't make much of a difference.

Thank you!!! can I get a second opinion(just to make sure) and is there anyway to make it fair for me? like, how much is cat and squid on their own?

i have no idea where they got the idea your side is equivalent to a nine '15 rares but that's not true. valuing your lemon candy as a '11 common, since it's a rather small and relatively common item, it's worth 2 '15 rares if you follow the 2;1 rule. the rest of your side is worth very roughly half a '15 rare, so your side is worth 2.5 '15 rares in total. even if we take a leap and assume the item is uncommon, that still only produces a value of ~5 '15 rares. nowhere *near* nine.

their side, on the other hand, totals out at around 2 '16 uncommons (or 0.25 '15 rares) following the same 2;1 rule. still very unfair to you. ask them to add something around the value of a '12 uncommon, which will bring their side up another two '15 rares.

[HennesseyCamaro]

my non swirl for there petsHelp! I rlly like this trade but I want it to be fair considering It’s my only omgsr and it’ll be hard to get another. Need as much help as possible!!

[cosmic~queen]

Not including the two unknown rarity pets, this is unfair to you. Their side adds up to just under 3 2015 rares; your side is just under 9 2015 rares. Since the unknown rarity pets are 2019 pets and unlikely to be more than uncommon, they don't make much of a difference.

Thank you!!! can I get a second opinion(just to make sure) and is there anyway to make it fair for me? like, how much is cat and squid on their own?

i have no idea where they got the idea your side is equivalent to a nine '15 rares but that's not true. valuing your lemon candy as a '11 common, since it's a rather small and relatively common item, it's worth 2 '15 rares if you follow the 2;1 rule. the rest of your side is worth very roughly half a '15 rare, so your side is worth 2.5 '15 rares in total. even if we take a leap and assume the item is uncommon, that still only produces a value of ~5 '15 rares. nowhere *near* nine.

their side, on the other hand, totals out at around 2 '16 uncommons (or 0.25 '15 rares) following the same 2;1 rule. still very unfair to you. ask them to add something around the value of a '12 uncommon, which will bring their side up another two '15 rares.

So no matter which way you look at it, it's unfair- thanks for the help!

[Kadmos]

Guys what you think about this trade? and does it reach the nonswirl value?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83760522&userid=864607&signature=76HdeT4ixjqLe4_p2MhUAQ

If not then i would really apreciate an advice on what should be added to reach the value of that pet ^^" Any help is really apreciated! Thank you much for taking your time to answer this~❤



.

[Falco]

Is a pink punk dog a fair swap for a blue sherbet? Thanks!

[DitsyDruid]

Would this be fair? Would I need to add and if so about how much?
Thanks in advance!

I dont know much about item rarity, but i have been involved in lots of item trades in the past. Depending on who you are trading, bulk items can go for much more. I traded 400 of my items for 15 09 rares and have gotten many similar trades, i wouldnt be surprised if that many items could of gone for more rares. I feel like youd have to add a lot for that many items, but again it depends on how each of you value the items.

im sorry if this was useless but i hope it helps haha

Thanks! Didn't really know that bulk items could go for that much as I've had several bulk trades where I've only traded about 3-5 09' rares.
Could I get a second opinion?