The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Meduz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83682371&userid=363145&signature=L8Koqn00rUH86VIDIDTXaA


Is this fair

I also have a couple of other offers

[haruyuki]

Would this be fair? I'm not very good with trades involving VR's...
Thank you in advance~

[GreenteaLatte]

is this fair?

It's unfair to the Tribal. I believe the top isn't even worth a mainlist.

Would this be fair? I'm not very good with trades involving VR's...
Thank you in advance~

This is unfair to the floppy eared blood dog. The dog is a 5th tier advent list while the valentine lion isn't on the list. If you do not follow the list, the lion would be overpaying since it's an earlier dated pet over the 3 months rule.

[SeaCrest]

Damn. Not on their part I think

Really unfair on their side.

As a mainlist rare pet the line tribal has more value than it's rarity value. You should also quote what you're replying to so people know which trade you are referring to!

Would this be fair? I'm not very good with trades involving VR's...
Thank you in advance~

You have a Flop Blood Dog, which is a Tier 5 Advent. The lion they are offering is not on the list at all. Rarity wise, it's fair, especially since theirs is an early 2009 VR and yours is a late 2009 VR, but if you go by the list it is unfair to you, I believe.

[nobxdy]

boop
It's unfair to me rarity wise but I wanted personal opinions.
Would you take this? c:
Thank you <3

[Perro]

I really need some good opinions on this trades/viewtrade.php?id=83662819&userid=878093&signature=BL3du3MYiMpqmGIGNe6Zfg

Would you accept the quality? If not what do they need to add?

(Gifting 2c$ for helpful responses)

Also should I?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78241617&userid=878093&signature=qzIGyYb8b9ZpERdrZtpdFQ

[daybreak.]

boop
It's unfair to me rarity wise but I wanted personal opinions.
Would you take this? c:
Thank you <3

I would not ^^'

The warrior is nice, but I think the store deer are quite coveted since they are popular designs and two could easily trade for more.

[nobxdy]

boop
It's unfair to me rarity wise but I wanted personal opinions.
Would you take this? c:
Thank you <3

I would not ^^'

The warrior is nice, but I think the store deer are quite coveted since they are popular designs and two could easily trade for more.

Thank you! Another opinion?

[<>Diamond<>]

anyone have any thoughts on this trade i got?

[nobxdy]

boop
It's unfair to me rarity wise but I wanted personal opinions.
Would you take this? c:
Thank you <3

I would not ^^'

The warrior is nice, but I think the store deer are quite coveted since they are popular designs and two could easily trade for more.

Thank you! Another opinion?