The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[evilpineapples]

Opinions please?

at a quick glance it looks to be unfair to you but id get a more in-depth answer from someone else

Hey guys. I've been on CS for a while but haven't really traded much on the rares list so I have little experience there. Can someone help me out and tell me if this trade is fair? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83689140&userid=198459&signature=9I84uQasAelMmr2abKpfog

Very unfair to you, not quite sure what their side adds up to but it cant be more than 2 or 3 '09 rares, whereas the jokerbun would be somewhere above the gap of the list. again, get another answer from someone else though because I dont know quite enough to give an in-depth answer of what its worth

[Perro]

I really need some good opinions on this trades/viewtrade.php?id=83662819&userid=878093&signature=BL3du3MYiMpqmGIGNe6Zfg

Would you accept the quality? If not what do they need to add?

[Aavea]

Did I make a fair offer ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83689302&userid=974483&signature=rR7FefLDOTP9nUqmY4Y0jg

[CelticKitty]

Caution: image heavy, but would this be a fair trade up? I'm cautious because it's taking allot of my rares for me even only slightly wanting the grinner....any help is appreciated.....
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83679154&userid=397255&signature=0-uRjJMeHMBU83jOquYw6g

Thank you, may I have another opinion?:)

Edit: thank you jjdiner! I appreciate the help!:)

[~Heizou~]

Caution: image heavy, but would this be a fair trade up? I'm cautious because it's taking allot of my rares for me even only slightly wanting the grinner....any help is appreciated.....
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83679154&userid=397255&signature=0-uRjJMeHMBU83jOquYw6g

unfair to you

Did I make a fair offer ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83689302&userid=974483&signature=rR7FefLDOTP9nUqmY4Y0jg

unfair to them

[SeaCrest]

one || would you personally take this trade? I know they're over rarity wise but is the demand for the malk pets greater?

[JJdiner]

Caution: image heavy, but would this be a fair trade up? I'm cautious because it's taking allot of my rares for me even only slightly wanting the grinner....any help is appreciated.....
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83679154&userid=397255&signature=0-uRjJMeHMBU83jOquYw6g

unfair to you

Did I make a fair offer ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83689302&userid=974483&signature=rR7FefLDOTP9nUqmY4Y0jg

unfair to them

trade 1. it is actually fair i believe

your side 40 09 rares + 1 t5 = 46-47 09 rares
their side:
grinner - 13-17 09 rares | (2 MA + early 09 R)
horse - 33-46 09 rares (5 MA + 1 LA)
total = 46-63 09 rares

so it is actually fair. that being said neither of these have great demand and quantity like this has a good deal of value itself so i personally wouldn't take it. still, rarity wise it is fair for both.
for the second trade, it is actually overpay on your side... your dog is a rerelease from 2009 meaning they should add another 2010 rare + a 2013 rare as well

please don't give false information

[UnworthyElevator]

I like this bid but is it fair due to the demand of C$? I really do like C$ though. Im very much considering accepting
Help please

[Moonlis]

Well, I actually have 2...

1 trades/viewtrade.php?id=83689190&userid=942472&signature=jeHB0y2nsv75E_TrgBLuSQ

2 trades/viewtrade.php?id=83689215&userid=942472&signature=zRH07V8b3haU6GrHk9ZP-A

Any opinions? Thank you ^-^

[JJdiner]

Well, I actually have 2...

1 trades/viewtrade.php?id=83689190&userid=942472&signature=jeHB0y2nsv75E_TrgBLuSQ

2 trades/viewtrade.php?id=83689215&userid=942472&signature=zRH07V8b3haU6GrHk9ZP-A

Any opinions? Thank you ^-^

your side is overpay for both trades