The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[silveriver]

I'm so bad with judging item trades. Any thoughts on this?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83593797&userid=8787&signature=Hc7AA-x1NgCAdR523IFW6g

[ShrimpSundae]

how's this trade?
thank you for any advice, it's such a huge help!

Quite a fair trade, the 2012 pet makes up for the difference in months I'd say

thank you! may i get a second opinion?

[♥HazelNightmare]

Would this be fair?

I know the Rare Items list values the pocky item at a 2008 rare/very rare. Can anyone weigh in on whether it trades at rare or VR worth? That's mostly what I'm struggling with in the above trade c:

Thanks!

Their pet using list is worth 7-8 09 rares, the pocky is listed as an 08 rare/very rare using the item guide ( Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=559754 ) If you value the pocky as just any 08 rare/very rare your side is worth 6 09 rares a 2010 rare and a 2011 rare. That’s without any demand of pocky which is up to you to determine .

[autumnsoundtrack]

Would this be fair?

I know the Rare Items list values the pocky item at a 2008 rare/very rare. Can anyone weigh in on whether it trades at rare or VR worth? That's mostly what I'm struggling with in the above trade c:

Thanks!

Whether you value it as rare or very rare is up to you. Though, I personally value it at a very rare because of how few I've found for trade, and because they're a popular item.

[Goldstarwolf]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83593993&userid=270579&signature=-z12O5aVRbxWIbGzAUR1bQ
fair?

[Yoshikage]

Need to know ASAP
Sent this trade asking what I should add,
Not sure how much I'm undertrading by..

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83594372&userid=855246&signature=vstwbsD-35YjGTCku9iJWA

[nobxdy]

I'm so bad with judging item trades. Any thoughts on this?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83593797&userid=8787&signature=Hc7AA-x1NgCAdR523IFW6g

According to the rare items guide, the totoro plushie should be worth an early '09 rare/very rare. Their side is worth a late '09 rare + the uncommon which doesn't do much. I personally think they should replace the 2015 uncommon with at least a 2009 uncommon to fill the date gap but it's up to you how you value your plushie.

[pochita]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83594593&userid=901300&signature=yMPbjVdezMl23TFoszmfnQ

Is this fair list and demand wise? Thanks in advance!

[Night~Rose]

Fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83586059&userid=968471&signature=CUCmSXJvumCNBxIrN2M1nw

help<3

[LunaGoneGreen]

Is this fair? Really need to know now.
Please pm me what you think
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83594739&userid=936494&signature=GdMfQHqpCkvqhoYc6KriUw