The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[faygeleh]

is this fair ?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83489763&userid=966372&signature=hhwQGSde9AX1ukZZ8-7-zg

honestly id say while it might technically be fair (which i personally wouldnt think so, maybe around 5-7 of the staff pups or so would do, but anything over that i feel is overpay even considering the older rarity there of the top) its pretty unfair in that right now the staff pets have pretty big demand and as far as i know the horse doesnt. they gave you one pet for all of those staff pets, which a lot of people might overpay for individually.

this is just my opinion and im still fairly new so def get a second opinion too

strongly disagree. these pups will probably only be uncommon at best, which i highly doubt since players are able to get 40 dogs *per person*, so it'll more likely be common/vc, maybe even OMGSC considering the amount of active players. 5-7 2019 vcs for a '12 rare is extremely unfair, even like 40 vc's for a '12 rare would probably still be unfair. its true that the ponies have bad demand, but considering the high amount of pets you can adopt at once, 1 older rare is plenty overpay for a decent amount of them.

Oof I have another trade. I think it’s probably fair but I want to get a second opinion first trades/viewtrade.php?id=83489836&userid=774404&signature=P61cnDQ8b7nKRYcmeLbJow

technically, its perfectly fair; each '16 store pet is worth a late '09 rare, and staff pets (especially older ones, and even the random/non-famous ones) have decent demand, but store pets demand is increasing pretty quickly and the tiger set tends to go for pretty decent overpay already. you could probably get a better offer, but that doesnt mean this one is bad. up to you!

[GreenteaLatte]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83489542&userid=867326&signature=krx3MgNN3UdCflrQodphSQ

Is this fair? I'd like help as soon as possible if possible,,,

Please correct me if I'm wrong, but this seem way unfair to them. You want two pets out of the Sob Set and they all have amazing demand and people pay lots for them. You are only offering one for the two and your items and 2016 rare do not add up to fill the gap for the second one. Again, this is my experience so please correct me if anything.<3

I disagree. A UR Aussie goes for around a non and 2 sorbs is 1 non. It looks like it's sllightly overpay with the other additional pets and items.

[LittleNinja]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83489923&userid=63360&signature=GdOuBIroi6vHPeqd2YCyPg

Is this fair?

[Fin72]

Oof I have another trade. I think it’s probably fair but I want to get a second opinion first trades/viewtrade.php?id=83489836&userid=774404&signature=P61cnDQ8b7nKRYcmeLbJow

technically, its perfectly fair; each '16 store pet is worth a late '09 rare, and staff pets (especially older ones, and even the random/non-famous ones) have decent demand, but store pets demand is increasing pretty quickly and the tiger set tends to go for pretty decent overpay already. you could probably get a better offer, but that doesnt mean this one is bad. up to you!

Ok. How much better of an offer do you think I could get for it?

[Ghoulflower]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83490003&userid=761439&signature=Fe4KZvA_R5B3tBpTbt7gPw

Would this be fair? Thank you

[GreenteaLatte]

Ok. How much better of an offer do you think I could get for it?

There is no set amount of 'overpay' you could get for this pet. Some may while some won't.

[LIONZ]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83485047&userid=946927&signature=xY6va4U2mCkWiMar-AuOqw Is this trade fair?

[MuddyPawprints]

is this fair ?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83489763&userid=966372&signature=hhwQGSde9AX1ukZZ8-7-zg

honestly id say while it might technically be fair (which i personally wouldnt think so, maybe around 5-7 of the staff pups or so would do, but anything over that i feel is overpay even considering the older rarity there of the top) its pretty unfair in that right now the staff pets have pretty big demand and as far as i know the horse doesnt. they gave you one pet for all of those staff pets, which a lot of people might overpay for individually.

this is just my opinion and im still fairly new so def get a second opinion too

strongly disagree. these pups will probably only be uncommon at best, which i highly doubt since players are able to get 40 dogs *per person*, so it'll more likely be common/vc, maybe even OMGSC considering the amount of active players. 5-7 2019 vcs for a '12 rare is extremely unfair, even like 40 vc's for a '12 rare would probably still be unfair. its true that the ponies have bad demand, but considering the high amount of pets you can adopt at once, 1 older rare is plenty overpay for a decent amount of them.

like i said im newer, i can only go off of what ive been told personally. and ive had my trades for unknown rarites cancelled outright when i offered rares, and i was told it was because unknown rarities are considered rare until they get a rarity, and those were just regular monthlies. your criticism is appreciated, but i still think in this specific case that many could be considered overpay for one pet, rare or not

[Inuru]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83476901&userid=961046&signature=hhCGIYHuhAsGMqB6Uy0Zww
thanks in advance!

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83490003&userid=761439&signature=Fe4KZvA_R5B3tBpTbt7gPw

Would this be fair? Thank you

1 2015 store pet is worth 40-45 C$, so the top of the trade totals to 80-95 C$.
(C$ values were pulled from the "How Much Is This Pet Worth In C$" thread.)
Excluding any factors such as demand, this is unfair to you by 25-40 C$.
Demand is entirely up to you to decide as demand varies from user to user.

Personally, I see this as a decent trade as store pets generally have good demand.
From past experience, I've also had no issues trading away any store pet from that set.

This is just my personal take on the trade. Feel free to get another opinion! :)