The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eneynde]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83484285&userid=6275&signature=h2xtlFqerh9-jXDGwa9Nag

I'm not very good with item values. Thank you in advance!

[sal.fisher]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83487802

I'm not sure the conversion rate for C$ to rares or conversely rares to C$ so thank you in advance for helping me out!

[LittleKitten570]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83488022&userid=970876&signature=gJy33_b8kGe4aHmYZNcmxw
Is this fair? I'm thinking it's not, but I'm still very new so I'm not certain tbh

[♥HazelNightmare]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83487802

I'm not sure the conversion rate for C$ to rares or conversely rares to C$ so thank you in advance for helping me out!

Wrong link you posted but you can look at the C$ guide Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3915876

[Mavi]

link
I would love a couple of opinions on this I know the peas have horrible demand but I'm really up in the air since I really like the Cheshire ;-;

[mak.]

ive been wanting this malk forever so i want to know if it was fair? if i was over then idrc because i got my dreamie, but please lmk !! ive been asking for a while.


trades/viewtrade.php?id=83481109&userid=917674&signature=ToOSd_norKzvRKcq_s_5LQ

[superfroglover]

Not good with items, is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83484789&userid=751924&signature=ESOW30iZ9ghjgG2OuLZD3A

Hasn’t been answered yet

Here’s another trade

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83488030&userid=751924&signature=xEXSIpkRUGVyW5VrGvD9bw

Still waiting on these two

[faygeleh]

Not good with items, is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83484789&userid=751924&signature=ESOW30iZ9ghjgG2OuLZD3A

Here’s another trade

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83488030&userid=751924&signature=xEXSIpkRUGVyW5VrGvD9bw

Still waiting on these two

first one is definitely overpaying and unfair to them, the first 3 items alone would be overpay since theyre all from 2009 (egg from easter, hat and stocking from christmas), though im not sure about the inner tube-- the oldest item on your side is from the 2011 medieval fair. your items might be a bit more visually appealing, but theirs hold more overall value, and christmas items tend to have decent demand. i'd take it.

second one is extremely unfair to you. even if you're going off the "old common = newer rare", newer rares will almost always have more value than old commons. they're easier to use as trade fodder for trading up, while older commons are only valuable in quantity. besides, even if that wasnt the case, using the year+ rules, 2014 VC = 2015 common = 2016 uncommon = 2017 rare. so your rare alone would be ""fair"", ignoring all other reasoning and demand. its just overall unfair to you.

[TagCattledog]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83486819&userid=422319&signature=q_x8Xn5lU6ZBgOvq-1SOyQ

Is this fair? I know the butterfly wolf is a list pet.

Bumping this cause it got pretty buried.

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83486819&userid=422319&signature=q_x8Xn5lU6ZBgOvq-1SOyQ

Is this fair? I know the butterfly wolf is a list pet.

Bumping this cause it got pretty buried.

All their warrior cats are worth a 2010 rare because of being extended into April 2010, so their side is worth 1.5 '09 rares together.
If you value your pet by the list, your pet is worth 3-4 '09 rares so it'd be unfair to you.
If you trade by years (since your b-wolf was released in 2009), it's only worth 2 '09 rares, so it's still unfair to you.

Up to you how you value each side demand wise though.