The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[JJdiner]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83377588&userid=749173&signature=dNQfMFhXLnZxSL9rLVMrdA

can someone help me out with this please? :”3

since the 2008 VR = 2008 VR,
2008 VR > 2017 VR,
PLUS there's a 2018 OMGSR,
they're actually overpaying

i agrgee that they are overpaying, id say that your side is just worth a non, however could you explain this a little better? it doesn't make sense to me

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83377588&userid=749173&signature=dNQfMFhXLnZxSL9rLVMrdA

can someone help me out with this please? :”3

since the 2008 VR = 2008 VR,
2008 VR > 2017 VR,
PLUS there's a 2018 OMGSR,
they're actually overpaying

nonononoononnnononononoo -hysterical screaming- those are rereleased pets. every year on 18th december the site will "release" or bring back older pets, most of which are insanely more valuable than regular releases of that year. there's an explanation on that here.

their side roughly adds up to a non and a sorb or so (not entirely sure what the blue ballon goes for in sorbs now, so somebody correct me if i'm wrong).
your side adds up to 2-3 sorbs, or just under a non, due to the fact neither are true dates and for some reason that matters these days. i'd accept, but get a second opinion and please please PLEASE do not value either of those as a '17 vr.

[huskypawz]

Light Leopard + Dark Leopard + ?? = Winged Wood Dog

What needs to be added to make this fair?

Can I get some more opinions?

[choom choom]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83377588&userid=749173&signature=dNQfMFhXLnZxSL9rLVMrdA

can someone help me out with this please? :”3

since the 2008 VR = 2008 VR,
2008 VR > 2017 VR,
PLUS there's a 2018 OMGSR,
they're actually overpaying

i agrgee that they are overpaying, id say that your side is just worth a non, however could you explain this a little better? it doesn't make sense to me[/quote]

(super super sorry amarok! i misread the trade a bit!)
im not too great at this, but in my opinion...
Their 2008 very rare is equal to the other persons 2008 very rare
and their 2017 very rare is actually a re-release of a 2008 very rare, so its equal to the other persons 2008 very rare, although it may be considered worth less than a true date
on top of that, the other person is giving them a re-release OMGSR, so even if it is decresed in value, its still an overpay on the other persons side.
hope this helped?

[JJdiner]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83377588&userid=749173&signature=dNQfMFhXLnZxSL9rLVMrdA

can someone help me out with this please? :”3

since the 2008 VR = 2008 VR,
2008 VR > 2017 VR,
PLUS there's a 2018 OMGSR,
they're actually overpaying

(super super sorry amarok! i misread the trade a bit!)
im not too great at this, but in my opinion...
Their 2008 very rare is equal to the other persons 2008 very rare
and their 2017 very rare is actually a re-release of a 2008 very rare, so its equal to the other persons 2008 very rare, although it may be considered worth less than a true date
on top of that, the other person is giving them a re-release OMGSR, so even if it is decresed in value, its still an overpay on the other persons side.
hope this helped?

im very sorry if this comes off as rude, but please don't give false advice, or advice if you don't know the pets values as well. we don't want to confuse anyone if possible
1. not all 2008 vr dogs = eachother
2. even though these are septembers each go for a sorb or half a non
3. both of the 08 dogs together on the other side are worth less than half of each of the 2 dogs on this side.

again it is correct that they are overpaying, but the reason as to how they are, is very important. just adding an omgsr wouldn't fix ir or make it fair, you would need to add maybe 22ma, the same value as the balloon

[amarok.]

this ?
thank you ,

oh, that's quite a fun one. if we value each of those larger turtles as a '12 uncommon, that'll make them worth a '14 rare or so. even ignoring the other items that's a pretty solid trade to you.

[JJdiner]

this ?
thank you ,

oh, that's quite a fun one. if we value each of those larger turtles as a '12 uncommon, that'll make them worth a '14 rare or so. even ignoring the other items that's a pretty solid trade to you.

id actualy say your side is overpay, maybe 2.5 '10s so they should add a 2010 rare, 2011 rare, 1 2014, + whatever is the value of the tag

[Stripe12]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83381292&userid=949329&signature=-iRz2xiDs9CmnrLOVldoDw

Pretty sure something needs to be added to their side, but I'm not sure how much.

Thanks in advance!

[madisong]

is this fair for my liontail set?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83380775&userid=939791&signature=H_NwNuoyL-hoffrA5DfhhA

[snowdrake]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83381292&userid=949329&signature=-iRz2xiDs9CmnrLOVldoDw

Pretty sure something needs to be added to their side, but I'm not sure how much.

Thanks in advance!

actually, their lions are store pets and worth a 2010 rare each, so they are overpaying by quite a bit.