The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[daybreak.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83379429&userid=953222&signature=edY8PyZ8wIAyavm2GeJbGg

is this fair? i like the pet but how big is a 4 month difference?

The monthly difference between store pets isn't too big. Both of those are generally considered to be worth a mid '10 rare but could fetch more according to people's preference. You might persuade your trading partner to bridge the difference by adding a WL uncommon, but if you like their pet better I'd say the trade is fine c: You might want a second opinion.

trade 1
trade 2

how's both of these? thank you for any help!

Those are both the same link ^^' Rarity-wise they're overpaying a bit, as a 2017 store pet is generally valued at an early 2010 rare. However, those PPS store pets have excellent demand – I'd say your griffin has better tradeability than any of the pets they're offering. Up to you which you prefer c:

is this fair ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83379490&userid=576089&signature=ssMkBhvC6_3px0CQGIZodw

would you personally accept this trade considering demand of the horse ?

If you go by list values, I believe this is fair. The store deer swap fairly, I believe. The carousel horse is a Tier 2 Advent worth 4-5 '09 rares. Minus the store deer, their side is worth 5 '09 rares according to generally accepted store pet values.

It's a good quantity of store pets to trade for the carousel horse, I think. It's really up to you whether you think you could get a better offer for it, as well as whether you'd like to trade down to fill some gaps in your collection or you'd rather use it to trade up/swap.

Since I'm personally trying to save my list store pets for trade ups, I wouldn't accept this trade. But that's mainly due to my personal goals; considering the demand for the carousel horse, I'd personally have no trouble with the trade. The pets they're offering generally have good demand as well.

[Mochichimchim]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83378368&userid=887658&signature=GIvCBv2HTME5amOJts-Wtw

I think this is fair because they are both nons but I'm not sure if I should accept

[Sarin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83378368&userid=887658&signature=GIvCBv2HTME5amOJts-Wtw

I think this is fair because they are both nons but I'm not sure if I should accept

It is a fair swap. It’s up to you which of the non dogs you would rather have! ^^

[daybreak.]

bid 1 bid 2

i'm running an auction, how are these in level of fairness, rarity and date wise?

I think both of those are unfair to you, though the second bid is I think a bit better c:

Generally a single 2016 store pet is valued at a late '09 rare. Neither of those offers amount to 4 '09 rares. Additionally, I believe a full set should be able to trade for a bit extra, though that's a personal opinion c;

[rody]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83377588&userid=749173&signature=dNQfMFhXLnZxSL9rLVMrdA

can someone help me out with this please? :”3

[huskypawz]

Light Leopard + Dark Leopard + ?? = Winged Wood Dog

What needs to be added to make this fair?

Can I get some more opinions?

[choom choom]

Light Leopard + Dark Leopard + ?? = Winged Wood Dog

What needs to be added to make this fair?

Can I get some more opinions?

could you link the trade?

[choom choom]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83377588&userid=749173&signature=dNQfMFhXLnZxSL9rLVMrdA

can someone help me out with this please? :”3

since the 2008 VR = 2008 VR,
2008 VR > 2017 VR,
PLUS there's a 2018 OMGSR,
they're actually overpaying

[huskypawz]

Light Leopard + Dark Leopard + ?? = Winged Wood Dog

What needs to be added to make this fair?

Can I get some more opinions?

could you link the trade?

It's not a trade yet! I'm just trying to figure out what the gap is. I've been told once that a rose pps needs to be added and then another time that a red x pps needs to be added.

[JJdiner]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83378865&userid=837651&signature=wAWZ8UtKxtsbmeTXjhT3sw id like to get another opinion on this, is it fair by the list, i believe the last person left off that it is actually worth 5ma + 1la which would account for the 4 09 rares

could i just get conformation that its fair?