The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[madisong]

hello!
I’ve sent these two trades today for an Eat/Drink me set
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81322513&userid=939791&signature=z9c_OC5D-qU_MWgeK0I9cA
and
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81321482&userid=939791&signature=MD83COUqor9QTCFfeIjeOA
would either of these be fair? Thank you!

[Soloee]

Is this trade fair?
I'm not good with rare-trades :P

[Strawberry_dreams]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81323804&userid=603163&signature=B-G3wDujKlY2BM3K9n7JNQ

is this fair, or how much overpay is it?

[madisong]

hello!
I’ve sent these two trades today for an Eat/Drink me set
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81322513&userid=939791&signature=z9c_OC5D-qU_MWgeK0I9cA
and
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81323844&userid=939791&signature=i47exxZsLHctZcsNaYuByw
would either of these be fair? Thank you!

[Lilo.]

I got another trade I would like some help with.
warning: bulk trade.
x
edit; this too x

[Strawberry_dreams]

Is this trade fair?
I'm not good with rare-trades

this isn't fair to you if you add their 2013 together that equals a 2012 and then if you add the 2012 they are offering a 2010 and a 2011 to make it fair they would need a 2011 or something else.

[Exo-L]

hello! is this fair? thanks for whoever helps!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81321632&userid=696811&signature=NUhauF_N06lVXHgcITKvVQ

[Creativity]

How's this, factoring in demand?

[Strawberry_dreams]

I got another trade I would like some help with.
warning: bulk trade.
x
edit; this too x

both are overpay but they are fair. the first trade has a lot of pets with really good demand plus 2 OMGSR not to mention all of those '08 VR and the advent and September list included so I think it would be good to accept bothers the second trade has 3 main list and the 2 OMGSR but thats just my personal opinion. I could be wrong. another opinion would be good

[Niragi]

I got another trade I would like some help with.
warning: bulk trade.
x
edit; this too x

Since the list is discontinued, it’s up to you if you still go by it’s values, however I’d personally not take the first trade; your side is valued at roughly 7-8 nons due to demand whereas the only older more valuable ex-list pets on their side are a liontail (~2 nons) and the dragon pps (~1.5 nons). Even if you consider the quantity of older Rares, their side only adds up to about 4 maybe 5 nons. Demand is up to you however~

The second trade adds up to about 4.5 nons, your ur tiger is worth 5 nons if you follow the list values, if you don’t it’s entirely up to you on how to value these pets and their demand~ It’s not a bad trade, but they should add at least about a sorbets value in my opinion.