The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[hexcore]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81306514&userid=778766&signature=LYVqzHpQzlWdib6Bbt3Cbg

Is this fair? Thanks!

Edit: also this
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81306535&userid=778766&signature=S6IIAbBrwe_WUmS2zwrWjw

[Creator0]

This? There is a high chance I’m underpaying, I’d just like to know.

Sorry to say again, but you're underpaying. There's quite a bunch of '10 rares, however the '10 rares are mostly quite low demand, although some are higher. The items aren't worth much as most of them are free and are recent. Your side will probably add up to at most a high september - a low mainlist

[Jughead Jones]

Quick answer? Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81307032&userid=964187&signature=SBdgXJxQX4m98w03PoirkA

edit- One more opinion? Let me make it clear that I do NOT follow the list. And please don't be snappy and say "no, that pet is worth way more than those rares"(nothing against the person that said this), to me It's very rude. I am using this thread because I am a new player.

[Koikee]

Quick answer? Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81307032&userid=964187&signature=SBdgXJxQX4m98w03PoirkA

no, it isnt.
the ur foal is worth more than a couple of rares

[hexcore]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81307142&userid=778766&signature=mYrOLfO-YN3jFBEpPmLveg

Would you do this? I do want c$ for it but I didnt know it was listed at such a low price

[Camden]

Quick answer? Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81307032&userid=964187&signature=SBdgXJxQX4m98w03PoirkA

edit- One more opinion? Let me make it clear that I do NOT follow the list. And please don't be snappy and say "no, that pet is worth way more than those rares"(nothing against the person that said this), to me It's very rude. I am using this thread because I am a new player.

I don't see that as fair at all. The UR foal can go for way much more than your pets. Based on the demand the trade isn't remotely fair. You need a huge amount of pets for the foal because it is a list pet, and most people do still follow the list.

[skyline]

Quick answer? Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81307032&userid=964187&signature=SBdgXJxQX4m98w03PoirkA

edit- One more opinion? Let me make it clear that I do NOT follow the list. And please don't be snappy and say "no, that pet is worth way more than those rares"(nothing against the person that said this), to me It's very rude. I am using this thread because I am a new player.

omgsrs, especially urs and their values, are entirely user based. so if you do not follow the list, or take demand into account, there really is no way to ensure that it is fair, other than that you, and the user that you're trading with like the trade. mostly everyone takes demand into account, even when not following the list. the ur foal typically trades for 1-1.5 nons.

to give you an idea, a non's list worth is about 1494-2016 '09 rares, granted, it is very unlikely you would actually be able to trade a non for that many rares, and that someone would even have and be willing to do that much, however, that's close to how high people typically value it demand wise when working with high value pets such as itself. urs are worth a lot, and the value of a non gives you an idea of how much, even if it's not entirely accurate. tried to explain that the best i could, ah.

well experienced traders and overall collectors, usually trade their pets for what they've been going for lately demand wise, since the list was retired, and because of how valuable the pet really is. so it'd be very difficult to get a pet such as the ur foal, or really any ur for 10-15 or so rares, even if you yourself do not go by the list, or take demand into account.

overall, because of this, i believe it is quite unfair to them, considering what the foal typically trades for, and is worth in general.

[Zelfie]

Help please! <3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81307241&userid=921063&signature=XEmKH7NN-h8yqhz_mQvntw

[Kassypen]

For the ur bee! Please make sure to take the c$ and whole trade into account.

x + x

I would love a very detailed answer as I’m desperate for the bee. But if not, that’s fine too. Thanks!

[gravity]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81303120&userid=865941&signature=UAZPlsXjp2t2Z9XSPhnQ6w

-> is this fair
Thanks for helping <3