The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[emrys]

Could I get more advice on this bid?

Boop

[popping star]

Some help on if these trades are fair or not?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80985513&userid=708017&signature=tfG4VTmi-kC87HTBe9_H4A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80995095&userid=708017&signature=vN-7aIPFXgWaO7ZP0xC0CQ

1st trade
It's unfair to the top. The top adds up to a late 2009 rare, a 2014 uncommon, and a 2018 rare. Your side is worth an early 2010 rare, a 2017 uncommon, and a 2018 uncommon. (2016 common = 2017 uncommon | 2016 very common = a 2017 common = a 2018 uncommon) Demand-wise, it's up to you. I personally value the zodiac dog at 1 2009 rare at most, so it'd be about fair for the store pet. Your chickens don't add up to the other pets on their side though. It's really up to you to decide demand values though.

2nd trade
It's unfair to the top as it's worth 2 2009 rares OR 4 2010 rares. Your side is worth an early 2010 rare.
Demand is, again, up to you as demand is subjective.

As a note, I went by how people generally value these pets. (e.g. 2009 very rare = 2 2009 rares)
Any personal values are up to you.

[Charbee]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80981467&userid=206448&signature=tZHCE4RSpC3pQ0saShw8Dg
Is this fair? I'm mainly trying to get pets that could help me get a UR Bee

[yourenowave]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80997600&userid=82270&signature=QRZ02SCX9eWvR4yonMSIRg


This is a lot to go through...

[skyline]

Could I get more advice on this bid?

Boop

i personally value the patchwork at 1 non. the sorbet at itself obviously, and the only other thing that really adds to the trade is the punk dog, which i've seen fetch high ex septembers, to even low ex mains. with that in mind, this offer (valuing the patchwork at a non) i'd value at roughly 1.7 nons. the sunback typically trades for 2-3 nons. i personally wouldn't accept this offer, and i feel you could definitely get more. however, how you value these pets is ultimately up to you.

[Words]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80997821&userid=641810&signature=8hZtfKXoij4Bo6oPA9_Yjg

Is this fair? I'd be happy if someone would help.

[luca_balsa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80997821&userid=641810&signature=8hZtfKXoij4Bo6oPA9_Yjg

Is this fair? I'd be happy if someone would help.

Personally, i wouldnt have taken this. Yes, the spotted tribal is a main list, but i feel you could have gotten more for your malk dragon. Ive had a Malk dragon and i got really good offers on it, but thats my opinion 😊
Get a second opinion though! As long as your happy, thats all that matters!

[Delest Wolf]

UR Apple+?=UR Peach

Help?

[Spinda]

Is this a paper clip challenge?

I keep seeing this word all over the place

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80998512&userid=958822&signature=s1pEK49CdIhlhxLkYFOJpQ

[nobxdy]

Is this a paper clip challenge?

I keep seeing this word all over the place

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80998512&userid=958822&signature=s1pEK49CdIhlhxLkYFOJpQ

It's unfair to them, the pets on your side are too recent to be worth a 2010 rare (their pet is a store pet, and store pets are typically worth more than normal pets).

A paperclip challenge is like someone trading you a slightly better pet for one of your pets -- normally people try going from an omgsc to an omgsr using the same pet. If you need a better explanation please feel free to get another opinion lol.