The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[honeycreeper]

does this look pretty fair? what's the demand on the UR Foal? thanks so much for any help!

how is this offer? it also includes the UR Foal!

honey

could i have a few more opinions please :>
what's the demand on the UR Foal? could i get a UR Bee with it?

[Jelissa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78174133&userid=148141&signature=7p0Qp7Z4McvehvsIaEreoQ

Is it fair?

[rats <3]

Hello! Would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80982720&userid=22963&signature=3mG0xxmfd_AFaahWD0D8Hw

[popping star]

Hello! Would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80982720&userid=22963&signature=3mG0xxmfd_AFaahWD0D8Hw

This is pretty fair to both sides of the trade!
(Here's the 'How much is this pet worth in C$?' thread.)

Mid 2010 rare (Guinea pig) = 25-30 C$
Early 2010 rare = 30-35 C$
Mid 2009 rare/very rare = 40-45 C$
TOTAL = 95-110 C$

How you personally value pets in C$ is up to you. c:

[Lothlórien]

Thoughts On This Trade?
I was just starting to understand everything with trades and now with the List Pets getting "booted" I have no idea about anything :? . I'm guessing demand is about the same regardless? Anyway I would love some thoughts on this trade! :)

[popping star]

Thoughts On This Trade?
I was just starting to understand everything with trades and now with the List Pets getting "booted" I have no idea about anything :? . I'm guessing demand is about the same regardless? Anyway I would love some thoughts on this trade! :)

If you still go by the retired list, some users do, this could be considered pretty unfair to you. The raven dog tends to fetch around 1.5-2 nons. (It could fetch more or less. It really depends on who you trade.) The top of the trade adds up to around a blue toxic. The list quantity is nice, but I personally wouldn't value their side at anything more than a purple toxic. It really depends on how you personally value the involved pets though! Any demand is up to you as demand varies from user to user. ^^

If you don't use the retired list, it's up to you how you value the involved pets.

[Lothlórien]

Thoughts On This Trade?
I was just starting to understand everything with trades and now with the List Pets getting "booted" I have no idea about anything :? . I'm guessing demand is about the same regardless? Anyway I would love some thoughts on this trade! :)

If you still go by the retired list, some users do, this could be considered pretty unfair to you. The raven dog tends to fetch around 1.5-2 nons. (It could fetch more or less. It really depends on who you trade.) The top of the trade adds up to around a blue toxic. The list quantity is nice, but I personally wouldn't value their side at anything more than a purple toxic. It really depends on how you personally value the involved pets though! Any demand is up to you as demand varies from user to user. ^^

If you don't use the retired list, it's up to you how you value the involved pets.

Thanks, this helps.

[rats <3]

hey, guys! what do you think of this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80985345&userid=22963&signature=yLAFviePHWH7LMS5ZST06w

[kadybeth123]

are these fair?
this

this

Im gonna assume this is fair but just checking (:

[GlimzyTheBee]

Is this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80985305&userid=964758&signature=JFqIRCIVHZc1DVJOAXREzw
Fair?

I think it's an over trade on their part, but I know squat about item rarity, apart from the few dates I vaguely remembered while scrolling through the archive.