The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[~Phantom]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80981764&userid=729613&signature=QEvcSgC1Sdt25g23T35PQA

Also agreed.
If you’re going literally
The lion is roughly fair for the zodiac (recent store pets are worth a 2010 rare each)

The lion itself is not fair. As recent store pets go for a Late 2010 rare. The other pets and items do not make the gap, they need to add a 2010 uncommon, possibly two to make the gap.

[Vanrouge]

Hi! I'm really rusty at ex-lists and would love some help!
How does this look?
Could I get away with taking a few off my side? Or adding to theirs?
Or are they already overpaying?
Thanks or any help!!!

Extremely unfair to you I'd say, their side usually only goes for 2 nons, whereas yours can get between 3-4 and have some very high demand pets in your side ^^

[~Heizou~]

Is this fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80981528&userid=957390&signature=3PaXsCmT4eZD30rAX6Ch5w

[Kittytalia]

Hi! What lists are in this trade, and is it fair?

[dogtreat]

Is this fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80981528&userid=957390&signature=3PaXsCmT4eZD30rAX6Ch5w

the dog is a 2009 VR and worth between 35-40C$
VRs sometimes fetch more than Rares C$ wise; but rarely 10 C$ more than the upper limit
so you overpaid by a bit for it.

[Lex.]

Is this fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80981528&userid=957390&signature=3PaXsCmT4eZD30rAX6Ch5w

Yep! 09 rares di usually go for 40-45 but some with good demand like the ornament or GSD or white feb go for more :>

[GreenteaLatte]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80981764&userid=729613&signature=QEvcSgC1Sdt25g23T35PQA

Also agreed.
If you’re going literally
The lion is roughly fair for the zodiac (recent store pets are worth a 2010 rare each)

The lion itself is not fair. As recent store pets go for a Late 2010 rare. The other pets and items do not make the gap, they need to add a 2010 uncommon, possibly two to make the gap.

I don't agree. I doubt the three month gap is worth a 2010 uncommon which is already half or one fourth of what the rare is worth depending on which ratio you use when you value rares and uncommons.

[Kittytalia]

Hi! What lists are in this trade, and is it fair?

[GreenteaLatte]

Hi! What lists are in this trade, and is it fair?

I only see a few advent lists. It's very unfair to you if you go by the list.

[Lex.]

Help please!
Offer for my OMGSR rat
Is this fair?
Thanks anyways

Would do it. OMGSR rats are really hard to trade off as is.