The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Draconica2014]

Hello! Can someone help me out with this trade?
Thank you!

[popping star]

Hello! Can someone help me out with this trade?
Thank you!

It's unfair to you. Your store pet is worth a late '09 rare.
The top adds up to 1 '10 rare, 1 '11 rare, 1 '12 UC, and 2 '15 commons/uncommons using the 2:1 ratio.
Using the 4:1 ratio, the top adds up to 1 '10 rare, 2 '11 UCs, 1 '12 UC, and 2 '15 commons/uncommons.
Any demand is up for you to decide. c:

[3000feet]

So originally I was only offering my Zebra (which I value at 2 nons) My Butterbun (which I value at 1 non) and my Leopard Jungle dog (which is an ex-September list). They added a lot to my side. I believe with what they've added my side is now worth over 4 nons, and the moonswirl was never worth more than that, even when it was on the list right? Or am I wrong and this us fair? What do you guys think?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80728025&userid=116838&signature=zVvDOFFuKhJYcMylDNSV3A

[MunchiiMoon]

How many gems/treasure would be fair for this cross-site trade? (Between CS and FR)

[.kaytlin.]

Is this fair? Thanks
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80728817&userid=186346&signature=jjXTlF9NQR9v_OpsFcavuA

[popping star]

Is this fair? Thanks
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80728817&userid=186346&signature=jjXTlF9NQR9v_OpsFcavuA

It's unfair to you. The top of the trade only adds up to a bit more than a 2014 rare.
Your pet is a 2010 rare. Any demand is up to you. c:

[Camden]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80728871&userid=889724&signature=0nL5fulsrtWvAqXHwSqu2w
Is this fair??

[Ironic Equation]

So originally I was only offering my Zebra (which I value at 2 nons) My Butterbun (which I value at 1 non) and my Leopard Jungle dog (which is an ex-September list). They added a lot to my side. I believe with what they've added my side is now worth over 4 nons, and the moonswirl was never worth more than that, even when it was on the list right? Or am I wrong and this us fair? What do you guys think?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80728025&userid=116838&signature=zVvDOFFuKhJYcMylDNSV3A

I mean personally I value the foal and zebra at 1.5 nons and the butterbun at 1, so that would add up the the 4 nons value of the moonswirl on the old list, without all the other stuff being needed. However I you could get moonswirls for less than their list value in trade down even before the list retired, and I don't think the list value is really accurate e.g. that a moonswirl is worth 4x a non dog.

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80728871&userid=889724&signature=0nL5fulsrtWvAqXHwSqu2w
Is this fair??

It depends on how you and your trading partner value the zonkey.
It's placed at 2 nons on the list, so that's where I'll value it.

Using the list, your side adds up to about the Pink Striped September tier.
Going by the list, it's very unfair to the zonkey as your side isn't even worth one-third of a sorbet.
Any demand and personal values are up to you and your trading partner. c:

As a note, all of my information is from the retired rares list.
If you do not use the list, values will likely be different.

[mthorsewhisperer]

is this fair?

thanks in advance! <3

may i have a second opinion on this?