The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[popping star]

A Malk Dragon is my ultimate dreamie so I don't mind overpaying a bit

But is this fair on my end?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80670936&userid=337343&signature=6lEJOWmws0Y24QTnLv_WtQ

I added on a Ghost Cat ( True date ) and a Roadkill PPS ( Dec 18th ) , and have it as a suggestion still, so they can add more things in ;w;

With the ghost cat and roadkill pps added, your side is worth about 12.5-14.5 '09 rares + a '17 rare.
The white malk dragon is worth about 38-50 '09 rares when following the list.
You'd need to add about 25.5-35.5 '09 rares to your side. Demand is up to you. c:

Note, .5 of an '09 rare is 1 '10 rare.

[Ranger of the North]

Kia ora! Is this fair? Thank you!

[myworld1000]

Kia ora! Is this fair? Thank you!

Very unfair to you

[popping star]

Is this fair to me?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80657942&userid=768234&signature=qDbsXlipHxS0eKpo3nRhew

Thank u for any help!!!

The other side adds up to about 12 '09 rares, a '13 rare, and a '15 rare.
If you follow the list still, that's barely worth a low September list pet.
It's very unfair to you as the UR pineapple is an above gap main list.
Any demand is up for you to decide. c:

[Blue_Aussie]

Thanks for the help... Could you help with these ones too???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80603662&userid=768234&signature=GQDpDbtpGz-N4pLHmdlfkw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80656372&userid=768234&signature=8AP9Vyf90fICi0VfPstq9g

Be very blunt pls, are they fair or not???

[nobxdy]

Thanks for the help... Could you help with this one too???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80603662&userid=768234&signature=GQDpDbtpGz-N4pLHmdlfkw

Be very blunt pls, is it fair or not???

I'd say the Joker Bun is overpaying by itself. The Warrior Cats set is worth about a Mid September List (if you still follow the list), and the Joker Bun is on the Main List (but clearly deserves to be up higher due to being OMGSR). The Warrior Cats set tends to go for Main Lists from what I've seen.

It's honestly up to you if you want this trade or not. (:

[popping star]

Thanks for the help... Could you help with these ones too???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80603662&userid=768234&signature=GQDpDbtpGz-N4pLHmdlfkw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80656372&userid=768234&signature=8AP9Vyf90fICi0VfPstq9g

Be very blunt pls, are they fair or not???

The second trade is unfair to you. The top side adds up to about 11.5 '09 rares and a '16 rare.
That's just below a tier 1 September list if you use the list's values. Your pineapple is a main list. c:

[Blue_Aussie]

Thanks for the help... Could you help with these ones too???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80603662&userid=768234&signature=GQDpDbtpGz-N4pLHmdlfkw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80656372&userid=768234&signature=8AP9Vyf90fICi0VfPstq9g

Be very blunt pls, are they fair or not???

The second trade is unfair to you. The top side adds up to about 11.5 '09 rares and a '16 rare.
That's just below a tier 1 September list if you use the list's values. Your pineapple is a main list. c:

Thank u... So the top trade isn't fair either???
Man, I don't get any good trades!!!

[nobxdy]

Thanks for the help... Could you help with these ones too???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80603662&userid=768234&signature=GQDpDbtpGz-N4pLHmdlfkw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80656372&userid=768234&signature=8AP9Vyf90fICi0VfPstq9g

Be very blunt pls, are they fair or not???

The second trade is unfair to you. The top side adds up to about 11.5 '09 rares and a '16 rare.
That's just below a tier 1 September list if you use the list's values. Your pineapple is a main list. c:

Thank u... So the top trade isn't fair either???
Man, I don't get any good trades!!!

I wrote about the top trade, it'd be unfair to the Joker Bunny if you follow the Rare's List:

Thanks for the help... Could you help with this one too???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80603662&userid=768234&signature=GQDpDbtpGz-N4pLHmdlfkw

Be very blunt pls, is it fair or not???

I'd say the Joker Bun is overpaying by itself. The Warrior Cats set is worth about a Mid September List (if you still follow the list), and the Joker Bun is on the Main List (but clearly deserves to be up higher due to being OMGSR). The Warrior Cats set tends to go for Main Lists from what I've seen.

It's honestly up to you if you want this trade or not. (:

[skyline]

Thanks for the help... Could you help with these ones too???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80603662&userid=768234&signature=GQDpDbtpGz-N4pLHmdlfkw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80656372&userid=768234&signature=8AP9Vyf90fICi0VfPstq9g

Be very blunt pls, are they fair or not???

The second trade is unfair to you. The top side adds up to about 11.5 '09 rares and a '16 rare.
That's just below a tier 1 September list if you use the list's values. Your pineapple is a main list. c:

Thank u... So the top trade isn't fair either???
Man, I don't get any good trades!!!

the top trade is overpay on their side if you go by the list, but taking in demand, it really depends on how you value your warrior set. despite is being worth about a mid september, i've seen it go for anywhere from a sorbet to a non.