The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[slushpuppie]

Hello everyone <3 Does this trade seem fair? I really liked it and it was so crazy to see so many pets being traded lol but I want to make sure it's fair for the other person too since they are offering such a large amount of pets - thank you for the help!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80633612&userid=846402&signature=5ldxGCNco6B2JNOoCPhhwA

this trade would be unfair to you

[maddi #;]

help~
this one too ;w;
last for now,,
i'm really bad at trades.. but would any of these be fair? or..

[delete myaccount]

Hello everyone <3 Does this trade seem fair? I really liked it and it was so crazy to see so many pets being traded lol but I want to make sure it's fair for the other person too since they are offering such a large amount of pets - thank you for the help!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80633612&userid=846402&signature=5ldxGCNco6B2JNOoCPhhwA

please don't accept this!
it's really unfair to the zebra, it was on the main list and worth way more than the build of store pets

[SoggyPeach]

I was wondering if this is a fair trade?

[xXPantherPawsXx]

Hello everyone <3 Does this trade seem fair? I really liked it and it was so crazy to see so many pets being traded lol but I want to make sure it's fair for the other person too since they are offering such a large amount of pets - thank you for the help!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80633612&userid=846402&signature=5ldxGCNco6B2JNOoCPhhwA

please don't accept this!
it's really unfair to the zebra, it was on the main list and worth way more than the build of store pets

Ah, I gotcha, thank you for letting me know! Luckily that's why I come here and ask for help ^~^

[madisong]

help~
this one too ;w;
last for now,,
i'm really bad at trades.. but would any of these be fair? or..

The first and last trade are both very unfair to you. The rose dog has generally good demand and even though it was placed at a mid/high September I’ve seen it fetch mainlists before. The second would be unfair to them as the leopard was placed higher than the red x dog. Though how you value these pets now it’s up to you. I personally wouldn’t accept any.

[popping star]

I was wondering if this is a fair trade?

The elemental malk set is worth 8 '09 rares. Any demand for them is up to you.
If you follow the discontinued list, the other side is worth roughly 8.5-9.5 '09 rares.
If you value ex-lists like regular rares, the other side is worth about 4.5 '09 rares.
Depending on how you value the involved pets, it could be seen as about fair or unfair. c:

Note: .5 of a '09 rare is a '10 rare.

[JSyle]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80640783&userid=412887&signature=Xk39sBMnSoLaI3dXinmLmg
And if so? Is this trade or the one below a better deal for me?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80635807&userid=412887&signature=gaWI4u3lZ38SZ9Gx6Bf2jw

[Hippiexxx]

Does someone can help me how I can make this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80632800&userid=833353&signature=FlR_8qhw9a2lbJRKszRCxQ

[popping star]

Does someone can help me how I can make this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80632800&userid=833353&signature=FlR_8qhw9a2lbJRKszRCxQ

2015 store pets are typically valued at a mid '09 rare.
Your side is worth about 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare. (I didn't include the items.)
You would have to add about 1 '09 rare + a '10 rare to the other side.