The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[McNoUsername]

Hey, is this trade fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80644699&userid=634280&signature=_m5fRMfCpGWlYNmz77qpzg

Thank you in advance

[SeriousBusiness]

Gosh is this fair? i dont really know what im doing i like the pets on my side but i want the sorb as well

[SeriousBusiness]

i'm not sure~
this one too ;w;
i'm really bad at trades.. but would this be fair? or..

the one on the first im not exactly sure so i guess you can wait for an opinion with that but for the second one all i know is that the dark leopard is so much more worth than the x dog below so it's unfair for the top since they're basically doing an over trade lol

[SnowFallenWebber]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80616603&userid=882438&signature=Iof95o9FodSl4miKS4CIrw

Got this offer for the 2008 UR Black sitting cat.

Got another
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80645795&userid=882438&signature=AO7T9K6cqCiYBmCdbk0WFw

[Thornes]

Hi, just to improve my trading efficiency and see if my offers were fair or not, would this have been fair?

And how up-to-date is this list?
2019 store pet = late '10 rare
2018 store pet = mid '10 rare
2017 store pet = early '10 rare
2016 store pet = late '09 rare
2015 store pet = mid '09 rare
2014 store pet = early '09 rare
2013 store pet = two '09 rares

[JSyle]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80640783&userid=412887&signature=Xk39sBMnSoLaI3dXinmLmg
And if so? Is this trade or the one below a better deal for me?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80635807&userid=412887&signature=gaWI4u3lZ38SZ9Gx6Bf2jw

[popping star]

Hi, just to improve my trading efficiency and see if my offers were fair or not, would this have been fair?

And how up-to-date is this list?
2019 store pet = late '10 rare
2018 store pet = mid '10 rare
2017 store pet = early '10 rare
2016 store pet = late '09 rare
2015 store pet = mid '09 rare
2014 store pet = early '09 rare
2013 store pet = two '09 rares

It's unfair to you. Your side is worth 5 early '10 rares.
The store pet side is only worth 4 mid '10 rares.

[Thornes]

Hi, just to improve my trading efficiency and see if my offers were fair or not, would this have been fair?

And how up-to-date is this list?
2019 store pet = late '10 rare
2018 store pet = mid '10 rare
2017 store pet = early '10 rare
2016 store pet = late '09 rare
2015 store pet = mid '09 rare
2014 store pet = early '09 rare
2013 store pet = two '09 rares

It's unfair to you. Your side is worth 5 early '10 rares.
The store pet side is only worth 4 mid '10 rares.

A alright, thank you! c: (I was fairly sure it was overpay on my side, but it got cancelled so just wanted to be sure!)

[sorashinny]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80646234&userid=309698&signature=yxFW98z5Zywt-9tp_x0Q5A

IS this fair? thank you

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80646234&userid=309698&signature=yxFW98z5Zywt-9tp_x0Q5A

IS this fair? thank you

If you still follow the discontinued list, it's unfair to the store pet. Their pet is worth 3-4 '09 rares.
All of your cats either were released in 2010 or had an extended release until 2010. That means your side is worth 2 '09 rares.
Any demand is up for you to decide on as demand varies from user to user. c: