The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[dogtreat]

I really want the lost city lions and the stocking cats. Couldn't find them anywhere else. Is it fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80644456&userid=32287&signature=mOBDoOu4ktSd9nPUmEFnmQ

incredibly unfair to you on the 2011 rare alone. their side does not even equal a 2012 rare.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80641208&userid=345279&signature=tmot3MASEoy-1993zGFcCQ

thoughts?

i would consider this unfair, but only Slightly. the lions are worth a late 2010 rare each, which technically is an '09 rare worth. but the warrior kitty often fetches overpay, so I'd personally be asking for an extra 2010 or maybe 2011 rare ^^

[SnowFallenWebber]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80616603&userid=882438&signature=Iof95o9FodSl4miKS4CIrw

Got this offer for the 2008 UR Black sitting cat.

[panda:3]

1.

2.

Think I might put these up for auction because of the trades I’ve been getting.
Surely they’re unfair to the other person? Any help on these two would be great thankyou x

I’d put them up for auction personally. I’d say they have more demand than the unickorn so the first would be unfair to you, but unfair to them rarity wise if you go by that. The second Is ok. If you’re looking to trade up then it’s a good option.

Thankyou so much for your help.
Second opinion?? X

[Minibug ♡]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80645600&userid=925477&signature=yi5vA57r4DqrejGj8ciKdA
Thanks for any help

[Annabeth00]

thank you!
just received this offer as well

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80644920&userid=345279&signature=SMvw-d_tKuZAs15EKXJQdA

[SnowFallenWebber]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80616603&userid=882438&signature=Iof95o9FodSl4miKS4CIrw

Got this offer for the 2008 UR Black sitting cat.

Edit: Got another offer
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80645795&userid=882438&signature=AO7T9K6cqCiYBmCdbk0WFw

[luca_balsa]

Please Help!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80645804&userid=821137&signature=18iwewcX-F6VHNIFCF6_vA

[popping star]

aaa Im super confused! Would this trade be fair? Thank you <3 if not what should they add?

It's unfair to you. Your side is worth 5-6 '09 rares if you follow the rares list.
The other side is only worth 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare, so they'd need to add 2.5-3.5 '09 rares.

Note: .5 of an '09 rare is a '10 rare.

thank you!
just received this offer as well

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80644920&userid=345279&signature=SMvw-d_tKuZAs15EKXJQdA

It's unfair to you. Your sitting cat had its release extended until April 2010, so it's worth an early '10 rare.
That 2018 store pet is worth a mid-late '10 rare as its release went until 2019. Any demand is up for you to decide. c:

[Splashing ponds]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80645849&userid=938023&signature=9sKrAaIZRqewgY25TsIbuA
is this fair please awnser

[popping star]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80645600&userid=925477&signature=yi5vA57r4DqrejGj8ciKdA
Thanks for any help

It's unfair to the top of the trade. Their side is worth 3 '09 rares.
Your PPS is only worth 2 '10 rares or 1 '09 rare.