The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[세레비]

Please help me with this trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820719&userid=825069&signature=alLRD5l9NbxzJkjfW-99WQ

The top is technically overpaying. Your Store Pet is worth a mid '10 Rare, and everything else in your side is worth the 3-months rule. Adding up the VCs and valuing a Common at 2 VCs, your side is worth a mid '10 Rare + 1 '18 Common + '15 Rare + '18 Rare. The Store Pet aside, these pets aren't adding up to the massive time gap between their '11 Rares and those pets.

Are they overpaying?

Well, yes! As explained on my previous post, their side is worth a lot more due to the fact that your side can't add for much more beyond their '10 Rare. Their '10 on its own doesn't completely cover the Store Pet since it's considered a late '10 Rare, but all they would've needed to add to make up for the gap is an Uncommon from the same year (in my opinion). The added '11 Rares is overpaying for not only the Store Pet, but the rest of the trade.

[Kittywittyboo]

Are they overpaying?[/quote]

Well, yes! As explained on my previous post, their side is worth a lot more due to the fact that your side can't add for much more beyond their '10 Rare. Their '10 on its own doesn't completely cover the Store Pet since it's considered a late '10 Rare, but all they would've needed to add to make up for the gap is an Uncommon from the same year (in my opinion). The added '11 Rares is overpaying for not only the Store Pet, but the rest of the trade.

[/quote]

Ok thank you I will let them know I’m going to add or change

[skybristle]

Link.
I'm pretty sure they are overpaying, and they said that they'd be willing to add more. I'm the side with the skelepup.
Even if it's slight underpay they included a lot of pets i like!

[Reki.]

Help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820967&userid=758592&signature=kcykUP0pbDIAek6zT19syQ

[skyline]

would a moonswirl and two sorbets be a decent trade for a sunback? (demand wise of course) or would i be better off keeping the sunback?

huge thanks for any opinions! <3

[InsaniTiny]

Is this a fair trade?

Thanks in advance!

[Hellagia]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79753884&userid=17787&signature=Immdx2LqbPl88pr9vTftlQ

May I get some help on this? Please?

[xBunx]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79753884&userid=17787&signature=Immdx2LqbPl88pr9vTftlQ

May I get some help on this? Please?

Unfair to you as the horse is a 2008 vr, worth 2 0'8 rares

[skybristle]

Link.
I'm pretty sure they are overpaying, and they said that they'd be willing to add more. I'm the side with the skelepup.
Even if it's slight underpay they included a lot of pets i like!

[obliviious]

any help with this?