The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79718407&userid=302965&signature=xJw_zzae5Ni3c-sO_cv9Cw is this trade fair? i have no idea how much that dog is worth at all but i remember the dice dogs were in a bit of demand during the event they were in

It's unfair to you. Just one of the uncommons on your side would be plenty.

[zero.two]

this?

thank you <3

EDIT: this one, too!

1. Going by the list, unfair to them rarity-wise. You would need to add a balloon dog to be fair to the toxic. The other two rares don't make much of a difference

2. Unfair to you. Tier 5 Advents = 6-7 Mixed 09 Rares, they're only paying a little bit more than 5

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79718407&userid=302965&signature=xJw_zzae5Ni3c-sO_cv9Cw is this trade fair? i have no idea how much that dog is worth at all but i remember the dice dogs were in a bit of demand during the event they were in

They don't have much demand anymore, from what I've seen. The two uncommon would be fair.

2016 common = 2017 uncommon = 2018 rare

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79720726&userid=629467&signature=zSKMZJ83jHZJGSb7cuv9VA
Is this fair?? I feel like they're over on their side but I'm not too sure.

Quite unfair to them. One 2014 uncommon is overpay on its own

[musicgurl333]

I'm pretty sure this trade is unfair to them, but would you personally accept it? Please note that I value all store pets as an '09 rare or above. Thanks for any advice!

[zero.two]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79727477&userid=907285&signature=iag6Svf8N7vhANGmJr1PIQ
Help is appreciated! <3

I'd say it's unfair to them because of the extra pets other than the '08 VR and 09' rare, but it depends on how you value the Kitsune demand-wise. It's only worth an early 09' R - 08' R, but it seems to go for quite a bit more because so many people love their design (like myself)

This is what I paid for mine, for reference

I did overpay a bit rarity-wise, but it was a huge dreamie of mine C:

[Chocolate_Chip]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79719829&userid=907615&signature=qYzTGZrWAhjO-OQInHi2Og
Is this fair if not what can be added? Thank you!

Any other opinions?how many more rares would I have to add?

[gryffzen]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79727758&userid=447885&signature=g6gJAD2oEVXkQhQu6F5oiA

would this be a fair trade?? ^ovo^

[nobxdy]

boop
Is this how people normally value the fairy items? ^^
I'm not sure how "rare" they are.

[LionsforScottie]

What should I ask in return for these items?

Edit: Thoughts on this one as well?

[Ashara]

I don’t think this is fair but could someone help me, what would need to be added?

[drown]

I loosely follow the rares list, but I'm not exactly sure if this is fair? Any help is appreciated.