The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kuzya]

cutt
phecat’s side is an ‘09 rare + ‘09 uc worth, how is it unfair to the top user?
they’re offering phecat an ‘09 rare and ‘09 uc. theyre from the very end of the year but pretty much all of phecat’s pets are from the last third of the year as well

they have 12 '11s = 6 '10s = 3 '09s
1 rare = 4 ucs


(just me) for myself when i do quantity i do 3:1 instead of 4:1 so even if i did that it would be
3(4) ucs = 4 '11 rares = 2 '10 rares = 1 09 and not equate the 09 rare plus 09

oh, ive always done 2 uc = 1 rare
everyone does it different i guess 🤔

[Zelfie]

Which one is better?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79184238&userid=921063&signature=lflMYLeMT9loPfjpu4at-A

Or

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79173135&userid=921063&signature=jWpK3np2Ml-xV8WShEq_fA

or

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79100172&userid=921063&signature=MtXhNPeF6T3aX88sRBDwkw

Thank you!

Please help!

[JJdiner]

@jjd
the TD CEG is definitely harder to trade for and find to begin with. Remember that Black Advents aren't even rarer than their other Christmas dog advents. They at most go for a 1:1 non swap. ^^

im really sorry if im dragging this on, i just want to be sure, is it harder to get than the cerb do you think? in case they will only trade the cerb for the lion+ cat?

[Targaryen]

@JJDiner
nah, not harder than a cerb. Cerbs are store pets so they're really annoying to get people to let go off.

[Meoauniaea]

Would all this:

be fair for this one pet?

[JJdiner]

Would all this:

be fair for this one pet?

again, the first image does not show so we can't tell

[Førgøttën]

Is this fair? Would you personally accept?

I would. Their side might not equal an exact 4 nons as value isn't determined, but the galaxy is worth a good bit. The moonswirl has been harder to trade down with demand and having OMGSR quantity would be better IMO.

[Meoauniaea]

again, the first image does not show so we can't tell

The image loads just fine for me??

[JJdiner]

again, the first image does not show so we can't tell

The image loads just fine for me??

maybe post the link to the pet? idk maybe it is just my computer but i don't see that anyone else has answered your post

[Meoauniaea]

Is all this fair...

....for this one pet?