The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Redpanda]

Oh gosh bulk warning, 142 pets 18 items
Consists of:
-Non
-A few advent of different values
-Dark leopard
-tons of rares/store pets of different years
Is the quantity worth it?

Just the Non and the Dark Leopard are enough to pay for it. Here it really depends on how much both sides value the Cerb on. Technically it is worth 2 Mid Advents but people value it "usually" at a Non-worth, some may worth it more but they overprice it quite a bit like if it was worth a Moonswirl (it's sickening).

They're overpaying in my eyes, but I would definitely ask for a second opinion since I value the Cerb on a Non, others may not.

Thank you, may i get a second opinion?

[Byuller]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79132325&userid=942594&signature=uJhkx4R0ds6AMO73WUV8lg
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79208427&userid=942594&signature=M7-jNP8OH6_4jfQ2O0IXVg
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79208415&userid=942594&signature=3NJwgLHXXQ0XZRBUjKiaxw
Are these fair? Thank you for any help, it means a lot!

1. They're slightly overpaying there.
2. I can't really value the items since I don't know their value but new Store Pets are not worth that many 09 Rares, a 09 Rare is worth perhaps 4-5 New Store Pets so as I see it they're overpaying but as I said, I don't know on what are the items value, ask for a second opinion.
3. It's a fair trade if not overpay for you since it may be a VR 09 Cat but it is not a list pet and it's only real value is that it's a Warrior Cat.

[SoulStreamR]

Can I please get help for these two trades?
xxx
xxx
I still don’t fully grasp how to do List trades so thanks for any help!

[Byuller]

Can I please get help for these two trades?
xxx
xxx
I still don’t fully grasp how to do List trades so thanks for any help!

1. It's fair rarity wise but the BA has more value since it is quite hard to get, I personally wouldn't accept it.
2. Unfair to you, the UR Aussie itself is above the UR Malk so they're asking for overpaying and a quite big one.

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79208630&userid=633510&signature=pnLI7rabVNbW4Yi4k5Wo1w

This is extremly unfair to you, the Rainbow Mane is worth currently a Balloon dog & Scarf PPS or 24 Mid Advents or168 Mixed 09 Rares it may possibly be upped to be worth a Sorbet and the 4 New Store Pets together are not even worth a 09 Rare. Just the Non itself is worth 3 Sorbets or Ur Flower & Green Toxic or 248-252 Mid Advents or 1,736-1,764 Mixed 09 Rares.

[SoulStreamR]

Can I please get help for these two trades?
xxx
xxx
I still don’t fully grasp how to do List trades so thanks for any help!

1. It's fair rarity wise but the BA has more value since it is quite hard to get, I personally wouldn't accept it.
2. Unfair to you, the UR Aussie itself is above the UR Malk so they're asking for overpaying and a quite big one.

Thanks so much! Much appreciated!

[DarkestWerewolf]

Anyone able to help? I’ve got a couple bids for my Patchwork auction and would like opinions. I personally like Bid 1 and 4 but I’m not sure...

Bid 1

Bid 2

Bid 3

Bid 4

Would you accept any of them and why? Should I take one of them or can I get more for my patchwork? I’ve heard that their demand can fetch a sorbet so should I wait?

[madisong]

Can I please get help for these two trades?
xxx
xxx
I still don’t fully grasp how to do List trades so thanks for any help!

1. It's fair rarity wise but the BA has more value since it is quite hard to get, I personally wouldn't accept it.
2. Unfair to you, the UR Aussie itself is above the UR Malk so they're asking for overpaying and a quite big one.

Thanks so much! Much appreciated!

beware, the ur Aussie will most likely be moved down on the list due to it staying VR after the overhaul. Typically users, including myself, are valuing it at around 2 sorbets. This would be fair trade if you value your BA at a sorbet as well since the UR malk is getting a non and maybe a bit more.

[✧ strawberry ✧]

Ur pea = Ur strawberry? Rarity and demand wise, what am I better off with?

Ur Aussie = Ur Strawberry?

[DitsyDruid]

How do these trade look?
Trade 1- Store Pets
Trade 2- Bulk warning
On trade 2 please ignore the UR Tiger as I didn't mean to add it to the trade.

[Ironic Equation]

Can I please get help for these two trades?
xxx
xxx
I still don’t fully grasp how to do List trades so thanks for any help!

1. The quantity is nice, but you can probably get sorbet level for the BA, which would be worth more than their pets (: Totally up to you of course, but I personally wouldn't.
2. I'd consider this pretty fair without the red-x dog. The UR aussie should definitely be moved down below the malk when the Rares list is updated, so I'd value it about 2 sorbets and the BA at one. The malk has decent demand, so I don't think this is too bad of a trade.

Ur pea = Ur strawberry? Rarity and demand wise, what am I better off with?

Ur Aussie = Ur Strawberry?

I would stick with the strawberry demand wise, since it seems to be somewhat more liked and has the added value of being a 'new' UR. I would say it tends to go for a non to a bit over while the peas go for a non to a bit under. Rarity-wise I'd value them about the same, since we don't know which is rarer.

The aussie should move down the list due to its remaining very rare, making it unfair for the strawberry. Purely rarity-wise it is clearly worth less.

Anyone able to help? I’ve got a couple bids for my Patchwork auction and would like opinions. I personally like Bid 1 and 4 but I’m not sure...

Bid 1

Bid 2

Bid 3

Bid 4

Would you accept any of them and why? Should I take one of them or can I get more for my patchwork? I’ve heard that their demand can fetch a sorbet so should I wait?

Bids 1 and 4 are definitely the best here, but I wouldn't accept any of them. Pathworks definitely seem to be able to get more demand wise these days, including offers up to a sorbet.