The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[RinRandomtime]

I'm not to sure so which of these are the best offer? Also is it fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79052373&userid=899534&signature=CaPjPFJOA8w3nwFc8FQ3Jw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79034915&userid=899534&signature=CBoI4Iye0w0atnDiaL7MsA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79024683&userid=899534&signature=1ti81SJHoBjJj2h0w48bRg

[Ava Ire]

Are those fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79051043&userid=144398&signature=hB2MglkPYo7tyF1F6SRLYw

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79055765&userid=144398&signature=8pC5rTGsU0oMcavvqnTtfA
The rat will be moved up due to it's new rarity, right? So it's pretty unfair, I guess?

[PaintingDog692]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79070736&userid=944320&signature=6VVI-oRXdfMhEGTXRTTJaw

is this list worth trading for the PPS dragon store pet from 2014

[Jeandark]

Hi! I need some help regarding list trades. I have a white lolita that I'm willing to trade, and here's some of the pets that I'm interested in for her. What do you think? Do you have suggestions on how to make this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79070755&userid=105360&signature=vds5gIG2GzpOyTz9ept1TA

[Targaryen]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79059370&userid=906324&signature=UL6Y1vqZJ0V3MozqAaz-sg
I need urgent help please!

none of your items are valuable so unfair to them

Thank you,
Can I have a second opinion please?

Items are typically worth an uncommon of their year. Scenery items are generally pretty popular and hard to trade for, so it wouldn't be unreasonable to value them at a rare. I don't think the rarity math is worth working out (id have to literally go find the dates of each item and multiply it and compare to the 09 rare their side is worth). I personally wouldn't at all. Scenery items are so difficult to find and trade for again... it isn't worth losing.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79070736&userid=944320&signature=6VVI-oRXdfMhEGTXRTTJaw

is this list worth trading for the PPS dragon store pet from 2014

People value the store pet differently from a few 09 rares to a high advent. What you're willing to pay for it is up to you. The PPS is only worth 1-2 09 early 09 rares and is fairly common.

Hi! I need some help regarding list trades. I have a white lolita that I'm willing to trade, and here's some of the pets that I'm interested in for her. What do you think? Do you have suggestions on how to make this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79070755&userid=105360&signature=vds5gIG2GzpOyTz9ept1TA

Imo, you're asking for quite a bit for the Lolita. Lolitas tend to get a sorbet or just over with demand. The true-date joker can get up towards 2 nons. The other pets add up to a low main-list roughly but quantity is valued very highly, and how that's valued is up to both trading partners.

[honeycreeper]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79065264&userid=945117&signature=JRiaWgL1uRP7uRwmbEFJqw

I'm not very good at big trades, could someone help me (:


trades/viewtrade.php?id=79070105&userid=945117&signature=3xCGbJcRRFjdJ4lcHn8w-w

What about this one too?

[3000feet]

Ok guys so I have a bit of a predicament. It seems like the Mooswirl is going to be dropping down the list at the new update, so is it still going to be worth the same? I was originally going to offer 3 nons worth for one in a trade but should I wait it out to see where it ends up on the list placement? What do you guys think?

[jenny96]

IS this fair? =)

[muffy]

Ok guys so I have a bit of a predicament. It seems like the Mooswirl is going to be dropping down the list at the new update, so is it still going to be worth the same? I was originally going to offer 3 nons worth for one in a trade but should I wait it out to see where it ends up on the list placement? What do you guys think?

To be honest I would wait on anything that has just been turned into a omgsr or something that already is an omgsr just cause you dont know where its going to go

[Foxy_Creations]

Could be