The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[mqdi]

This fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=79025835&userid=948661&signature=P3MMqxyt7A3yC2BK6rwGBA

[jinbad]

This fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=79025835&userid=948661&signature=P3MMqxyt7A3yC2BK6rwGBA

Unfair to you. The pets on their side don't add up to the value of the BW.

[RiverRaven]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78866957&userid=686698&signature=n79KUxv6k87BfePa1cg2vQ
Was this a fair trade? I don't quite understand the new rarity system and was curious which side overpayed?

You overpaid. the rbm is omgsr and therefore worth more than the joker which i really dont see ever becoming omgsr. i personally would not have sent this trade but demand values are up to you.

I sent this as a bid before the rarity was changed, and after it got accepted. Demand wise is the RBM worth more than the joker, even though the joker is higher on the list?

[rosé]

are these both fair? if so, which one should i accept?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79016722&userid=952073&signature=yDpjle2aCR1yFVOEvfCFWw

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79025116&userid=952073&signature=HBhAzfgO4gNBvk4CkhRjuw

completely depends on how you value the red cerb. i value it at 2-3 nons. the raven at 1.5-2, and the beg at 1-1.5 nons. the first trade, i'd definitely consider. again, it depends on what you value the pets at. second trade is based on how much you value quantity. personally, i'd heavily consider both these offers

I just wrote up a reply on the last page ^^
I disagree with the beg trading for 1.5 nons. Only true dates fetch that, and even then it’s difficult. BEGs are only worth 2 sorbets, and people are assuming it’s really worth a non when it’s only demand that makes it that way. It’s demand on top of demand. It’s greedy. Nobody is really willing to pay 1.5 nons, people just ask for it.

My reply is on the last page if you wish to read it <3

oh, okay! thank you so much!

[Puptarts]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78866957&userid=686698&signature=n79KUxv6k87BfePa1cg2vQ
Was this a fair trade? I don't quite understand the new rarity system and was curious which side overpayed?

You overpaid. the rbm is omgsr and therefore worth more than the joker which i really dont see ever becoming omgsr. i personally would not have sent this trade but demand values are up to you.

I sent this as a bid before the rarity was changed, and after it got accepted. Demand wise is the RBM worth more than the joker, even though the joker is higher on the list?

the rbm is moving up the list with it now being omgsr i believe. not sure about demand

[mqdi]

This fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=79025835&userid=948661&signature=P3MMqxyt7A3yC2BK6rwGBA

Unfair to you. The pets on their side don't add up to the value of the BW.

Ok thanks!

[Miserybaby]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79025912&userid=247863&signature=ov-PYdZ3YOZDQnO_tzDxKA

is this fair for my VR 2009 sitting cat

[shadow~wolf]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79025482&userid=793839&signature=lH4TrNl3feExEO_4hD-_Aw

sorry for asking so much! is this fair? i really like the pets on their side but i'm wondering if it adds up.

[patriciaツ]

completely depends on how you value the red cerb. i value it at 2-3 nons. the raven at 1.5-2, and the beg at 1-1.5 nons. the first trade, i'd definitely consider. again, it depends on what you value the pets at. second trade is based on how much you value quantity. personally, i'd heavily consider both these offers

I just wrote up a reply on the last page ^^
I disagree with the beg trading for 1.5 nons. Only true dates fetch that, and even then it’s difficult. BEGs are only worth 2 sorbets, and people are assuming it’s really worth a non when it’s only demand that makes it that way. It’s demand on top of demand. It’s greedy. Nobody is really willing to pay 1.5 nons, people just ask for it.

My reply is on the last page if you wish to read it <3

oh, okay! thank you so much!

what people will trade for pets fluctuates immensely, however personally it's easy for me to get non + for a rerelease beg. a td beg at 1.5 nons+, that's just from my experience with trading beg/cegs

[jinbad]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79025912&userid=247863&signature=ov-PYdZ3YOZDQnO_tzDxKA

is this fair for my VR 2009 sitting cat

It depends on your rarity math.

If you go by 2 rares of one year = one rare of the year before, then yes it is fair.

4 '10 rares = 2 '09 rares

2 '09 rares = 1 '09 VR.