*DISCONTINUED* Rares List Guide (1 March 2019)

[lucky333123]

Pretty sure people will hate this idea but can we just revamp the list in the sense that all the OMGSR’s should be above any VR? It is dueable with the rarity changes. Obviously pets that were OMGSR before the rarity change will be placed higher than the ones that just changed and obviously ones that have been fluxating will be placed slightly higher than the ones that just changed.

not sure if i misunderstood anything but i agree with this.
also should the aussie be moved down? its the only vr above the gap now.

Yep. All the OMGSR’s should be above any VR and it BR should be on the same tier as an OMGSR because they aren’t compareable.

[SunRaes]

Pretty sure people will hate this idea but can we just revamp the list in the sense that all the OMGSR’s should be above any VR? It is dueable with the rarity changes. Obviously pets that were OMGSR before the rarity change will be placed higher than the ones that just changed and obviously ones that have been fluxating will be placed slightly higher than the ones that just changed.

I agree. (I love this idea!)

[King Andre]

I agree the Aussie should be below nons. While it’s important to not let rarity alone be the deciding factor in list placement; the cookie dog is not only more common than nons but I’m fairly certain it has worse demand as well.

[Edgeyworthy]

Pretty sure people will hate this idea but can we just revamp the list in the sense that all the OMGSR’s should be above any VR? It is dueable with the rarity changes. Obviously pets that were OMGSR before the rarity change will be placed higher than the ones that just changed and obviously ones that have been fluxating will be placed slightly higher than the ones that just changed.

I agree. (I love this idea!)

Same here! It wouldn’t even need to be the whole list, really just anything from September on would have to be scrapped (granted that’s more than half the list) but it’d work~

[myth;]

Did any pets loose their OMGSR status at all? Or list pets turn rare?

[lucky333123]

Did any pets loose their OMGSR status at all? Or list pets turn rare?

Nope

[PenguinQueen]

If the list is to be revamped, who will be in charge of it? Will it be someone new or will it be the same people as before? In my opinion, things might work better if multiple people are running the thread so it's not just one or two people who have control over whether things get discussed or not.

[DaDwarf]

Everybody is in control of what gets discussion :) if you want to discuss something, all you gotta do is post!

[Alina]

my opinion for some tier options:

Tier 1
Sunjewel = Moonswirl = Dogtag = UR Tiger

Tier 2
Plains Zebra = Grevys Zebra = UR B Wolf = 08 UR Cat = UR Banana

Tier 3
July PPS = UR Zonkey = UR Bee = UR Cucumber

Tier 4
Sunback = Coontail = Mountain Zebra

Tier 5
UR Phoenix = UR Cinnamon = UR Holly = UR Bengal = UR Foal = UR Peach

Tier 6
Nonjewel = Nonswirl = Nontag = Noncoon = UR Malk

Tier 7
Growing White July = UR Flower Pot = UR Lion

I used a lot of evidence from this post here and put pets in the same tier that changed rarities at the same time.

Of course this is nothing anyone has to agree on, but I think some of this is accurate.

I would really like to hear some opinions on this, of course it doesn’t include all above gap pets yet but I think it might be good if everyone send in some input!

[beemo]

@Alina, looks good! but i'd disagree with the UR Malk and UR Phoenix being lower than the UR Cucumber.

if we're trying this mostly rarities only list, i don't think any VR pets should above pets that were OMGSR prior to the update.

i think it should be like:

pets that have been omgsr the longest maybe throw in a little demand/popularity
etc
etc
pets that have fluctuated and when they went omgsr
etc
etc
pets that went omgsr with this update
then everything else