The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[iconerfatty]

Thoughts?? trades/viewtrade.php?id=78967745&userid=889555&signature=tPcI3XX9dwLikmmK__I06w

valuing the td ba at a non and the cerb at 3 nons this makes your side 4.5 nons tops.. i wouldn't send this trade personally but rarity wise it's extremely unfair to them as the sunjewel is worth 5 nons and you are offering some september lists and a little over a sorbet.

Alright, second opinion? Is the sun jewel hard to trade off?

[nobxdy]

Is this okay? xx

It's unfair to you by a little more than a Red Dragon tier.
I'd personally accept, up to you though.

[Eckobass101]

Is this okay? xx

It's unfair to you by a little more than a Red Dragon tier.

Thank u ^^

[dakotasarobot]

This?

[Redpanda]

Could I get some opinions on this?

[SunRaes]

This?

Hi!
That's extreme underpay to you. Their pets don't even add up to a low Mainlist.

Alright, second opinion? Is the sun jewel hard to trade off?

Unfortunately, yes. They don't have the best demand, either, and most of the people I've traded say that they're only willing to pay 4 Nons- I've even had someone say that 'it's worth 3 Nons so this is unfair to me'.
If you're willing to accept underpay, then go ahead. ^^

[SunRaes]

Alright, second opinion? Is the sun jewel hard to trade off?

Unfortunately, yes. They don't have the best demand, either, and most of the people I've traded say that they're only willing to pay 4 Nons- I've even had someone say that 'it's worth 3 Nons so this is unfair to me'.
If you're willing to accept underpay, then go ahead. ^^
(Ignore this, I forgot to edit my previous post!)

[Peppermint <3]

this?

[kkspecial4]

this?

Unfair to the bottom
The pets on the top side do not add up to even just one of the 2010 Uncommons on the bottom side

While, quantity trades are not meant to be exactly fair - this is quite unfair to the bottom
The top only adds up to slightly over 1 2013 Uncommon + 1 2014 Uncommon + 1 2015 Uncommon

Doing the math extremely quickly, so apologies if I made any mistakes

[Peppermint <3]

this?

Unfair to the bottom
The pets on the top side do not add up to even just one of the 2010 Uncommons on the bottom side

While, quantity trades are not meant to be exactly fair - this is quite unfair to the bottom
The top only adds up to slightly over 1 2013 Uncommon + 1 2014 Uncommon + 1 2015 Uncommon

Doing the math extremely quickly, so apologies if I made any mistakes

Thank you so much!