The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[KkSpecial]

This?

Thanks<3

Unfair to the bottom - rarity wise
The top only adds up to 1 2014 Uncommon + 2 2015 Uncommons + 1 2016 Uncommon

[Kaminarii]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78716765&userid=857986&signature=IQ6POF06HXy2LJuugiOATw

I’m not sure how close the worths of these two are

[Eevee]

THIS

And

THIS

The first trade is unfair to you. The koi is from 09 and the bat is from Halloween 10’.

The second trade, I do believe is also unfair to you. But I am unsure how much needs to be added to make it fair

[Purple Goober]

is this fair?

[KkSpecial]

is this a fair trade????

Unfair to the bottom
1 2008 Rare = 1 2009 Rare + 1 2009 Uncommon
The top is only worth 2.5 2009 Rares

Rarity wise the bottom adds up to slightly over 5.5 2009 Rares

A handful of the items on the bottom fetch 1 2009 Rare each on their own
Plus while the Zodiacs are only worth 1 2010 Rare rarity wise they have the potential to fetch more depending on your trading partner
Rare Items Thread

[TheLittleBlackCat]

Just wondering how fair this is:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78716794&userid=665708&signature=aV4qX1XMluDJpy0t-TyX8g

And how much is the ur strawberry currently going for?

[Purple Goober]

is this fair?

[beemo]

is this a fair trade????

Unfair to the bottom
1 2008 Rare = 1 2009 Rare + 1 2009 Uncommon
The top is only worth 2.5 2009 Rares

Rarity wise the bottom adds up to slightly over 5.5 2009 Rares

A handful of the items on the bottom fetch 1 2009 Rare each on their own
Plus while the Zodiacs are only worth 1 2010 Rare rarity wise they have the potential to fetch more depending on your trading partner
Rare Items Thread

it's not really fair to consider the zodiac's demand and then just value the card dogs regularly, seeing as they have demand also and easily go for more than 1 '09 rare + 1 '09 uncommon each.

[Nachtbringer]

How about this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78716714&userid=95327&signature=e02R78AEKZiv7u_-ynFh5Q

[Vexious]

How about this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78716714&userid=95327&signature=e02R78AEKZiv7u_-ynFh5Q

unfair to the blood dog, he is on the list and at the very least worth 4-5 09' rares.