The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[LegionWolf]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78701830&userid=7505&signature=rB6WmzN63I-a3TrbI3ZuIw

Event items for pets? Any help would be appreciated!! Thanks!

[clarke,]

considering demand, should i take this?

[Banana.]

x
Curious if this is fair (:?

seems like you've been needing help for a while so ill give it a shot hah

sorb- 83-84 MA
balloon dog- 21 MA
ur horse- 15 MA
then your side has another MA and then some assorted '09 rares (8), making your side worth 38-ish MA and sorbs are worth 83-84, so your side in all technicality is worth less than half of their side.
overall, I'd say a really good trade because it is unfair to them rarity wise and there is no demand here that would really balance it out. if I were you, I'd accept.

you might want to get a second opinion on my math tho c:

Omg this is super helpful !!!! Thank you!
Second opinions (:?

[GhostPants]

Alright, I have these three trades.
The one with the dragon egg claims it is the white malk dragon, but i really dont want to be fooled out of my pets. [they said i could wait but if it IS the white malk, is the trade fair?] White malk trade

And this one, im not fond of the black and white target litter, i just dont find them appealing and when i had the target dog i had to trade for underpay.. Target Dog trade

Another one, its fair rarity wise but i think i could maybe get more for it due to demand, Thoughts? Purple Sleipnir

Would any of you accept demand wise? Im not sure how much the Purple Sleipnir is and i keep getting trades for him or with him in it.. so he must have atleast good demand? Thank you for any responses! i appreciate any and all!!

- Gasoline

[bear]

Is this trade fair? (Demand and rarity?)
Thank you in advance!

[.Aurora.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78706778&userid=885940&signature=0OJeoUSZUyGXdxlE0ZnpTg
would you take this????
List trade

bop

[clarke,]

x
Curious if this is fair (:?

seems like you've been needing help for a while so ill give it a shot hah

sorb- 83-84 MA
balloon dog- 21 MA
ur horse- 15 MA
then your side has another MA and then some assorted '09 rares (8), making your side worth 38-ish MA and sorbs are worth 83-84, so your side in all technicality is worth less than half of their side.
overall, I'd say a really good trade because it is unfair to them rarity wise and there is no demand here that would really balance it out. if I were you, I'd accept.

you might want to get a second opinion on my math tho c:

Omg this is super helpful !!!! Thank you!
Second opinions (:?

i agree !! however, quantity has its own value; but i still think you're getting the better end.

[bee.kind]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78706778&userid=885940&signature=0OJeoUSZUyGXdxlE0ZnpTg
would you take this????
List trade

the nick unicorn is worth 2 sorbs and a red rose, where your side only has a sorb and a september list rat with some assorted rares and vrs (i don't believe the blue rat is on the list but I'm tired so i might've missed it). your side is far underpay pretty much by an entire sorb for the unicorn though I'm not positive if it fetches its entire value in trades c:

[Xeroxoe]

Malk:
Major bulk xxx
xxx
Cake dog: xxx
Thanks for any help!

[Cottonpaw]

These two?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73850961&userid=874117&signature=Geh1nE6jr8D7po5IdNFHHw
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78706665&userid=874117&signature=k1OWMk8eGvU3Xa-Vq6XZzA