The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[useless_demigod]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78565832&userid=821506&signature=AaP0IEPRX7Ho1Q4k3_9Ovw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78515560&userid=821506&signature=X8T5VSqTYEc9SPtyvheGFA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78569763&userid=821506&signature=25sy3IRogexkGeb5BqUphA

im wondering out of these 3 bids for an auction i have which one is the best with worth and how fair it is
Thanks in advance to whoever answers!

[Rulersrule]

Which trade would you accept? How's the demand for the pets they're trading? Thanks for any help c: Trade 1 Trade 2

[takiyena]

★ got a new bid i need help with, specifically with demand ^^
edit and bulk warning, ★ this too !

[волк.]

May I please get some opinions on this trade? Thanks in advance

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605740&userid=725620&signature=w4CMuLtvIkU95uShMkCwyg

nons are worth three sorbs: they’re only asking you for roughly 2.5 ? if im correct. looks like overpay on their side!

Agreed, they are overpaying.
Your side is worth about a nick unicorn tier, and the gap between this and a non is around a red toxic I think? However, I am talking simply rarity wise. Please get another opinion as I may be wrong, and wouldn't want to give you false advice.

[Heck.]

So I’m hosting two auctions right now and I wanna see which bids are fair (btw, I value the BMD a little over a sorbet) Also, these trade all are about demand, not just rarity

BMD:
1 - How fair is this? I mainly don’t like the C$ but I’d still like to know how fair it is :)

2 - This one is my favorite, but is it fair? A lot of tribals don’t have great demand and same for the cake dogs, so I’m still wondering

-3 - I think that this one isn’t fair, but this is just to double check

-4 - This too

-5 - I also think this is unfair, but what is the white Malk dragon going for?

250 C$:
1 - I’m really confused on this one, is it fair or under? (Demand wise as well)

2 - I know that this is technically fair, but how’s the demand for that rat? How low would I have to go to get something or would I just be able to do a tier swap?

[wwdits]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605926&userid=812575&signature=55inqP9v0MLke0TxZY0Yvg

i need help with this please, thank you;

[TheKwakiutlTribe]

I'm tempted to auto this, any opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605922&userid=710778&signature=pfJQORoVVhDWsxlteOZdVg

[dissy]

I'm tempted to auto this, any opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605922&userid=710778&signature=pfJQORoVVhDWsxlteOZdVg

100%
im gonna put in my auto from my auction in a second but id definitely auto that


edit;; trades/viewtrade.php?id=78389927&userid=423217&signature=RlBqn2IQ2NALMMU0qnhllQ

that was my auto

[dinolover519]

250 C$:
1 - I’m really confused on this one, is it fair or under? (Demand wise as well)

2 - I know that this is technically fair, but how’s the demand for that rat? How low would I have to go to get something or would I just be able to do a tier swap?

The first bid is definitely a lot of overpay. The 09 and 10 rares would be a relatively fair trade depending on on how much you personally value C$. Throwing in the store pets and rereleases, it quickly becomes overpay. However, they do have a lot of rats and horses, which often have lower demand compared to other species.

The second bid is fair, but in general, rats don’t have very high demand compared to other species. You could probably tier swap for one of the other paw print rats in that tier, but it’d be a tad harder to get to dog linearts, which generally have higher demand. However, if you’re trying to get list pets, this would be a better choice.

[Banana.]

I'm tempted to auto this, any opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605922&userid=710778&signature=pfJQORoVVhDWsxlteOZdVg

Yes! They are offering a tier 1 advent and this is not going to become uncommon. It’s just got demand right now but I haven’t seen it go for more than this.