The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Telemel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605670&userid=907285&signature=q19GEh4w5sWHqAbWmiUbTQ

Is this fair? It looks like overpay but would anyone accept this?

[Peppermint <3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78604392&userid=950482&signature=7nXpmWcJjfAbTJFHydTngQ

Not to sure on this one. Thanks in advance!

[волк.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605670&userid=907285&signature=q19GEh4w5sWHqAbWmiUbTQ

Is this fair? It looks like overpay but would anyone accept this?

From what I know, yes it is overpay.
The two pets from your side are likely to be uncommon and common pets, so one of those is an equal swap for the unknown rarity on thier side.
The rare pet and items on their side is definitely overpay.
However, get another opinion as I may be wrong. x

[Mets]

May I please get some opinions on this trade? Thanks in advance

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605740&userid=725620&signature=w4CMuLtvIkU95uShMkCwyg

[Telemel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605670&userid=907285&signature=q19GEh4w5sWHqAbWmiUbTQ

Is this fair? It looks like overpay but would anyone accept this?

From what I know, yes it is overpay.
The two pets from your side are likely to be uncommon and common pets, so one of those is an equal swap for the unknown rarity on thier side.
The rare pet and items on their side is definitely overpay.
However, get another opinion as I may be wrong. x

Yeah that’s what I thought, thanks for answering! <3
Any other opinions?

[clarke,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605670&userid=907285&signature=q19GEh4w5sWHqAbWmiUbTQ

Is this fair? It looks like overpay but would anyone accept this?

From what I know, yes it is overpay.
The two pets from your side are likely to be uncommon and common pets, so one of those is an equal swap for the unknown rarity on thier side.
The rare pet and items on their side is definitely overpay.
However, get another opinion as I may be wrong. x

Yeah that’s what I thought, thanks for answering! <3
Any other opinions?

i’d accept asap!

[clarke,]

May I please get some opinions on this trade? Thanks in advance

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605740&userid=725620&signature=w4CMuLtvIkU95uShMkCwyg

nons are worth three sorbs: they’re only asking you for roughly 2.5 ? if im correct. looks like overpay on their side!

[Heck.]

So I’m hosting two auctions right now and I wanna see which bids are fair (btw, I value the BMD a little over a sorbet) Also, these trade all are about demand, not just rarity

BMD:
1 - How fair is this? I mainly don’t like the C$ but I’d still like to know how fair it is :)

2 - This one is my favorite, but is it fair? A lot of tribals don’t have great demand and same for the cake dogs, so I’m still wondering

-3 - I think that this one isn’t fair, but his is just to double check

-4 - This too

250 C$:
1 - I’m really confused on this one, is it fair or under? (Demand wise as well)

2 - I know that this is technically fair, but how’s the demand for that rat? How low would I have to go to get something or would I just be able to do a tier swap?

[kxynine]

May I please get some opinions on this trade? Thanks in advance

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605740&userid=725620&signature=w4CMuLtvIkU95uShMkCwyg

nons are worth three sorbs: they’re only asking you for roughly 2.5 ? if im correct. looks like overpay on their side!

It'd be closer to 2 sorbs, I believe.
From what I know, blue toxic goes for sorb + red x pps (10MAs)

[SmittenDragonKitten]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78603073&userid=945336&signature=sJ3M3-fOYZxswtVPdgg8vw
is this a fair trade?