The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Evils]

There are 610 Pets on my side. I was just wondering if this trade would be worth it since it's taking a majority of my trade fodder.
I'm really tempted but would like some opinions of others who have been actively trading list pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78429414&userid=26479&signature=EuDu4vpACM2RVSn0YCdQ5g

I haven't actively traded for list pets in awhile, but I can confidently say that they are asking for a lot of overpay on your side. While the orange Cerberus is in a good demand among those seeking it, it is not worth that many rares and very rares, especially since most of them seem to be coming from '09 and '10 with a few from '08.
I think they may be trying to play it as you getting a good deal from it when you're really not, as they aren't asking for list pets. You could get a lot more for your pets than just an orange cerberus. I'd take a few more opinions as I've been away from the list trading game for awhile, but I do know that in calculating a C$ price comparison (this may not be accurate since comparing pets to C$ isn't always equal to value of the pet in pets), you would be overpaying by more than 5x, maybe even 6x, for sure as the Orange Cerberus is valued 505 C$ while an 09 rare could go for 30 c$ at best.
I know that a mid advent is valued at around 7 09' rares, but I'm just unsure how many an orange cerberus would add up to.

[Redbud]

how would my side be for their single gearback? and is the gearback easy to trade off?

[ChocoDog935]

Auctioning a Balloon Dog, and I got these two bids so far. Which is better, and which one can get me a BMD? Also, on a scale of 1-10 how would you rate these?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78429748&userid=937646&signature=p88mTBogoYR_43Af1FNzMQ #1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78430015&userid=937646&signature=h_xhz2wgenrQZVP41wIxwQ #2

Help Please? <3

[Targaryen]

There are 610 Pets on my side. I was just wondering if this trade would be worth it since it's taking a majority of my trade fodder.
I'm really tempted but would like some opinions of others who have been actively trading list pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78429414&userid=26479&signature=EuDu4vpACM2RVSn0YCdQ5g

Rarity wise, an Orange Cerberus is only worth a Balloon Dog - 21 mid advents - or around 150 09 rares. You're overpaying rarity wise by 3-4x it's value.

However - Orange Cerberuses tend to go for 4-5 nons regardless of list placement. This is the equivalent of over 1,000 advents or 7,000 09 rares.
That means... your side is technically underpay - demand wise.
However, I would note that quantity goes for extreme overpay a lot of the time.


Would I personally take it? Absolutely not. You're trading an extortionate amount of quantity which is insanely hard to come by, nevermind trade for. Cerberuses aren't too hard to trade for with a little bit of quantity quality lists and patience. I think you could get a better offer. That's just my personal opinion - mostly because I value quantity extraordinarily high.

[Targaryen]

[
Second opinion please?

agree. you can do better.

[justina valentine]

Hello!
Okay so I would like some opinions on this.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78425904&userid=769336&signature=b5XaTrjfToDbRC7D_eSFiw

+ some chicken dollars (their limit is 500)

I know this is unfair but I said I don't mind underpay if their is quantity c:



Got one opinion would like some more c:

Please <3

[Nicnova]

Is this trade fair?

I'm not much of an item person, I'm afraid

[Targaryen]

Hello!
Okay so I would like some opinions on this.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78425904&userid=769336&signature=b5XaTrjfToDbRC7D_eSFiw

+ some chicken dollars (their limit is 500)

I know this is unfair but I said I don't mind underpay if their is quantity c:



Got one opinion would like some more c:

Please <3

Even with the quantity, I still wouldn't do it - the quantity isn't even of "popular" or particularly "in demand" advents. I think you would be better off trading down for main-lists and then advents - you'll keep more value that way (:

[Gordon]

Should I take this offer of a Sunjewel for my raven, marionette, and clockwork bun? I’m honestly not very interested in the sunjewel, but it is very valuable. But then again I’m trying so hard to complete my store pet collection, and these store lists were hard to get and I just really like them. Could I get these store lists back again with the sunjewel? Or should I stick with my store lists?

I'd keep the store lists, especially if they were hard to get, since it might be harder to trade down with the sunjewel

Thank you! Could I get some more opinions?

[Targaryen]

Should I take this offer of a Sunjewel for my raven, marionette, and clockwork bun? I’m honestly not very interested in the sunjewel, but it is very valuable. But then again I’m trying so hard to complete my store pet collection, and these store lists were hard to get and I just really like them. Could I get these store lists back again with the sunjewel? Or should I stick with my store lists?

I'd keep the store lists, especially if they were hard to get, since it might be harder to trade down with the sunjewel

Thank you! Could I get some more opinions?

agreed