The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[miyoni]

thank you in advance for the help !
x

[✦ nemuri]

i know nothing about list trading so! time to get some help. is this fair? i might not accept it because i do have a level of attachment/sentiment towards some of the pets because they were gifts, but i’m curious to learn in order to re enter the trading game wkfnmsnfmskfk

also need help with this trade! ^^;;

1. personally i wouldn’t just because I hate trading up
2. it’s fair but i wouldn’t because i prefer to stay on the list

aa thank you ! may i get a second opinion on the first trade? ;w;

edit; oops this trade came in as well. i read somewhere that a 2015 store pet was worth a 2010 rare, so what’s the rate for a 2014 store pet? how much rarer is a 2009 rare compared to a 2010 rare?

[Sardonyx]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78406982&userid=785388&signature=C8Ao5lG8wBMh_B2x4vUr9A Is this trade fair? If not what needs to be changed?

[Arataki]

Fair? Demand wise?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78404073&userid=941852&signature=k0Kr3iuo4lyMBimBGcwJEQ


Help!

[brownponygypsy]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78405169&userid=378579&signature=TApOh6apyxWyB7ExuBA5oQ
For my I do not think so but I would like some help please

[bre <3]

Is this trade fair? If not, how much C$ would be needed to make it fair?

i wouldn’t accept this. i’m not that great at determining the worth of c$ (because it honestly depends on how much you personally value it, and whether or not you are able to easily purchase it). but, i would never accept this myself, it’s a horrible deal in my opinion.

[Looperslair]

Hello, is this trade fair?

Demand wise the bmd usually goes for at least balloon dog to a sorbet at most. It really depends on how you value the pet.

So, no this is not fair to the bmd.

[Ironic Equation]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78405979&userid=369442&signature=coTq_t2USkgp3kU-QdNvUw
They've edited, would you personally do this?

By the way, I'd always advise anyone asking on this thread to get a second opinion as people value things differently and I've seen some false advice while going through it.

[drown]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78407100&userid=804583&signature=uLZfElbtAq2zyMFJyLIkEA
Is this fair for my tier 5 cat, demand included?

[bre <3]

hey, i’m trying to figure out if these are fair trades!
not sure whether or not to accept them, as i love the husky. also, if this isn’t fair, what’s the husky worth? someone please help, i’m really not sure.
(also, the trade with the bunny and the pps fox could potentially have the pps griffin added to it, or replace something)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78295181&userid=845730&signature=2J-lq33kwgq7XmriVTSs7g
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78377456&userid=845730&signature=2iXjC1GfsQWuFv7x-lX3Fw

desperate for some help