The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[bre <3]

hey, i’m trying to figure out if these are fair trades!
not sure whether or not to accept them, as i love the husky. also, if this isn’t fair, what’s the husky worth? i’m in desperate need of help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78295181&userid=845730&signature=2J-lq33kwgq7XmriVTSs7g
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78377456&userid=845730&signature=2iXjC1GfsQWuFv7x-lX3Fw

[Mets]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78404251&userid=833901&signature=UKwTjXCepHtGuAi6AHkKPg
Opinions on this trade?


(Ur galaxy cat vs 1046C$ + 108 2018 store pets)

Seems like overpay on your side, mainly because the demand for the UR Galaxy PPS Cat is undetermined at this stage, though still very popular. It depends on what your trading partner values the UR Galaxy at.

Any other opinions?

If they value the cat at a non just the c$ would be fine
Non= 1040 c$

I think you’re overpaying quite a bit
It really just depends on how they value the cat and since there isn’t a set placement

[Banana.]

Hi everyone! I have this trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78405924&userid=322734&signature=F7Xcb-LbFGrDh5G0srpB4A
I'm pretty sure the items are worth more than the two cats, so about how many items should I have to make it fair?
Thanks for any help

I can look in the archives for their year if you need me to but generally, depending where you value your items, items are worth a common-uncommon of the same year.
Unless they are items on the item rare list, which none of yours are (:

[kunikida]

Good evening!

x ---- in desperate need of help with this offer!

Thanks in advance for any help xx

I wouldn't personally with the shima.

Many thanks x
Could I snag another opinion from anyone?

[sunstream.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78406165&userid=891090&signature=1fFLXym6d-gabpz_WPIgMg
In desperate need of help, really appreciate replies!

[Looperslair]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78406024&userid=891090&signature=ooyIjwaNVZnxbkRMOb5scA

Help! :000

For a blue toxic
Sorbet + dark leopard = just under being fair (add about 2 tier 7 advents)
Sorbet + light leopard = unfair (add tier 12 September list)




Either way this trade is unfair for the blue toxic.

This is not taking in account for demand.

[Illusive]

Hi everyone! I have this trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78405924&userid=322734&signature=F7Xcb-LbFGrDh5G0srpB4A
I'm pretty sure the items are worth more than the two cats, so about how many items should I have to make it fair?
Thanks for any help

I can look in the archives for their year if you need me to but generally, depending where you value your items, items are worth a common-uncommon of the same year.
Unless they are items on the item rare list, which none of yours are (:

Few of the items are from 2017’s Lost City Summer event, by the way
. The sealed statement could be counted as a common as a lot were released, but the other items are uncommon or rare.

[ZiggyKitten97]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78406108&userid=947655&signature=mMoMypNEtfVYBspM8oOkRA

This?

(Warning BULK)

[Beaniebunny]

How much would I need to add for a ur peach if I offer a sherbet?

[ZiggyKitten97]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78406108&userid=947655&signature=mMoMypNEtfVYBspM8oOkRA

This?

(Warning BULK)