The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[armads]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78306115&userid=862978&signature=ks_reFp_AvN-JskoZXHr0A

This is fair?

unfair to you. your caterpillar will be a tier 5 Advent, worth 75C$ or 6-7 '09 rares. depending on that cats exact TD release, it might be close, but I wouldn't take it imo.

[Smaug The Dragon]

Assistance please;
1. <---- Tempted for this
2.
3. <---- this I really need help for!

Thanks for those who helped! Can I have another opinion?

[Begs]

PLEASE NEED HELP I DONT WANNA LET IT SIT
Is this fair for a purple toxic if not what side needs to add what
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78303626&userid=858203&signature=vGLu3tnEhgmsZp7Ho13MyQ

[armads]

xxx
And
xxx
Thanks for any help!

both very unfair to you. your box is a Sept. tier 8. their pink Sept is only tier 5 and the random pets don't fill the gap. the holly cat is an advent and no where near the same value.

[Requiem;]

Would a pineapple be a fair swap for a GWJ demand-wise? (What do you personally think)

Thank you!! <3

Neither have spectacular demand so I would say its up to preference.

Which one of these trades would you personally take?

Trade 1 - I know this one is technically overpay but is it worth it with demand and the quantity involved? Would you personally accept?
or
Trade 2 - Would this offer be better to take? What does the dragon usually go for with demand?

Any help is appreciated. c:

Personally I wouldn't take the first trade. I prefer quantity, and Sorbets aren't super easy to trade off. Not hard, just generally easier to trade when used as filler than straight trading it off. But, its up to you! Its certainly overpay.

I am not familiar with the date of the re-release, but the lion is worth 5-6 '09 rares and the 7th tier is worth 6-7. Malk dragons tend to go for fair to slight overpay, sometimes more depending on who you trade with. You do have to keep in mind the heart huskies are fairly popular and tend to get fair to slight overpay, so its your preference.

[then]

fair?

[Begs]

PLEASE NEED HELP I DONT WANNA LET IT SIT
Is this fair for a purple toxic if not what side needs to add what
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78303626&userid=858203&signature=vGLu3tnEhgmsZp7Ho13MyQ

[Reirin]

xxx
And
xxx
Thanks for any help!

the cake dog on your side (will grow up to be this pet) is worth 6 mid advents. the first trade is unfair to you since their pink striped september dog is a tier 5 september list pet (while your pet is a tier 8). the other pets on their side don't even add up to a low advent so it doesn't cover the gap. also, in my experience, the pink striped september dog doesn't have the best demand and is a bit hard to trade off.
the second trade is highly unfair to you since their side is only worth 1 mid advent and the 15C$ doesn't cover the gap.

[weld]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78306651&userid=815492&signature=UbemwB56xg-8AYOjm920XQ how should i change it? or is it fair?

[W3rewolfrock]

thanks for helping

Is it a fair trade?
Merry Christmas/happy holidays
-Wolfi