The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Wolf Storm]

PLEASE NEED HELP I DONT WANNA LET IT SIT
Is this fair for a purple toxic if not what side needs to add what
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78303626&userid=858203&signature=vGLu3tnEhgmsZp7Ho13MyQ

Its unfair. Demand wise its a terrible trade as the toxic goes for fair trades while the tribal does not (hard to trade off). The cake dog goes for fair trades. Rarity Wise I believe they’re off by 2 balloon dogs but thats an estimate (I believe its a balloon dog + add)

[SOUP!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78303102&userid=582005&signature=Aq85UKw4V3FJeEL6u8ozpA
Would this be fair? Thanks c:

[home]

xxx
I just sent this trade; is it fair? tysm in advance c:

[nataliia_sophiia]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78304482&userid=250092&signature=LabgJ239vx7pbxOSbbn3XA

Could I get confirmation that this is a fair trade?

[Jvnxed]

Assistance please;
1.
2.

For the first one,

the blue dragon PPS is a tier 2 mainlist pet, and your marionette usually goes for a sorbet, so it's unfair to the marionette. Not sure about the second trade.

I'd get a second opinion c:

[Banana.]

PLEASE NEED HELP I DONT WANNA LET IT SIT
Is this fair for a purple toxic if not what side needs to add what
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78303626&userid=858203&signature=vGLu3tnEhgmsZp7Ho13MyQ

Sorry I’m deleting my advice bc I saw someone else’s and I was entirely off

[Wolf Storm]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78304585&userid=925400&signature=BJ3vM42-fJjowNeh5k2wvQ

Help??

unfair to you

Is it only because of the uncomun on my side?

Their side- 2014 Egypt, 2009 Christmas

Your side- 2013 Christmas, 2009 Staff b-day (June).

For the rares, their side is about 6 months off. The same goes for the uncommons (about 6-7 months).
Even if you removed the uncommons, it would still be unfair. Both sides have fairly good demand with the uncommons fetching fair trades and the rares too (the lion may get over trades)

[plutone]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78304585&userid=925400&signature=BJ3vM42-fJjowNeh5k2wvQ

Help??

unfair to you

Is it only because of the uncomun on my side?

if you take the rare off your side it will be more fair

[Smaug The Dragon]

Assistance please;
1.
2.

Thanks for those who helped! Can I have another opinion?

[LionKingdom]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78304585&userid=925400&signature=BJ3vM42-fJjowNeh5k2wvQ

Help??

unfair to you

Is it only because of the uncomun on my side?

if you take the rare off your side it will be more fair[/quote]

But the baby lion is from 2009