The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[TooSpooky]

okay im kinda drunk on candy, so please correct me if im wrong, but this can’t be possibly fair, right????
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78295027&userid=953678&signature=QUnVKT2zLtlfE7gTMPB3tA

Unless their pet is secretly a list then that's definitely unfair to you, if your wanting to edit the trade then I would take 3 store pets off and the unknown rarity then I believe it may be fair, if I'm wrong please correct me

[Targaryen]

hi! is this fair?
what’re the demand values of their pets?

UR Pineapples tend to get valued around 1-2 sorbets depending who you trade. I wouldn't say their side even fetches a non-dog together, which is half the value of the coontail.

The coontail can get at least 1.5 nons ^^

okay im kinda drunk on candy, so please correct me if im wrong, but this can’t be possibly fair, right????
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78295027&userid=953678&signature=QUnVKT2zLtlfE7gTMPB3tA

'16 rares are worth early 2010 rares each. Their dog is from 09 or worth two 2010 rares. I would remove at least two store pets and the cat for it to be closer to fair.

[E c s t a s y ☆]

okay im kinda drunk on candy, so please correct me if im wrong, but this can’t be possibly fair, right????
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78295027&userid=953678&signature=QUnVKT2zLtlfE7gTMPB3tA

Unless their pet is secretly a list then that's definitely unfair to you, if your wanting to edit the trade then I would take 3 store pets off and the unknown rarity then I believe it may be fair, if I'm wrong please correct me

This is definitely unfair to you.
Their dog doesn't even worth all of your 2016 store pet.

[Targaryen]

okay im kinda drunk on candy, so please correct me if im wrong, but this can’t be possibly fair, right????
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78295027&userid=953678&signature=QUnVKT2zLtlfE7gTMPB3tA

Unless their pet is secretly a list then that's definitely unfair to you, if your wanting to edit the trade then I would take 3 store pets off and the unknown rarity then I believe it may be fair, if I'm wrong please correct me

This is definitely unfair to you.
Their dog doesn't even worth one of your 2016 store pet.

That's not true either. Their dog is from 2009 and worth two 2010 rares (or two '16 store pets). Please don't give false advice.

Their dog is a late 09 rare, however. So you may want to ask them to add something to cover the date gaps between the two store pets and the dog.archive.

[Targaryen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78291932&userid=849678&signature=IC0u-9jgy_l1gUSCroYh6g
Haha yeet help

Non-TD BMDS typically go for around a balloon dog, which is half the toxic's value alone.

However, growing BMDs are fairly in demand and could probably fetch 1-2 sorbets while they're still growing if you look around c:

[spencer]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78291932&userid=849678&signature=IC0u-9jgy_l1gUSCroYh6g
Haha yeet help

Non-TD BMDS typically go for around a balloon dog, which is half the toxic's value alone.

However, growing BMDs are fairly in demand and could probably fetch 1-2 sorbets while they're still growing if you look around c:

Still unfair to them by rarity though.

[Pokeilope]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78291547&userid=160999&signature=aXcQ3xQG_XY4ghWTbdQLpA


How much would have to added to be fair?

[abandondacc]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78255027&userid=947870&signature=dkUPUb3cIHCMmr32onEMzg Is this fair

[Foxx.ie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78202173&userid=950038&signature=dy3QCX9Azc9vTjt2ooqZDA

Can someone please help? <3

[monochromia]

hi! << is that fair? I know the ur butterfly goes for more, but will it be incredibly hard to trade with the demand? What are the other pets?? ^^ tyyy