The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[dinglebingle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78222454&userid=813435&signature=Vd6WvwSmfdwJkfZAUY7j-w
or
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78223901&userid=813435&signature=GKkbX1D-VWhn4mzsnkAq2g

#2 is much fairer than the first one, the first one would be worth maybe an advent list, which is very unfair to you. If I had to choose, I'd go for #2, although it is up to you to decide

[WeirdWhiteStarDoggo]

What one should I accept?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78178904&userid=830519&signature=HxnC3Yay-3MRrJEU5R6scA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78184601&userid=830519&signature=dFZhJMV5rU8v7SgImuln7w

Sorry but I’ve been asking for help on this for a while would appreciate if anyone could answer me❤️❤️

sharp cheddar cheezits those are huge trades hhhh gimme a moment to break down the values per side

for this trade
they have,,,
1 grinner - tier 2 september
1 tufted blood dog - tier 5 advent
1 BMD - tier 6 september
1 purple heart husky - tier 7 advent
1 grey border collie - tier 7 advent
t6 sept + t2 sept + 2 t7 adv + t5 adv = (2 Early '09 Rare Dog & 31-38 Mixed 09 Rares) + (12-16 Mixed 09 Rares & Early '09 Rare Dog) + 2 (7-8 Mixed 09 Rares) + (6-7 Mixed 09 Rares) = 3 early '09 rare dogs & 63-77 mixed '09 rares so like 65 to 80 '09s

your side,,,
red android - t5 adv
angry + shy basilisk - 2 t2 adv
zebra + grey + white carousel horses - 3 t2 adv
pink alien dog - t2 adv
all 4 fluffies - 4 t2 adv
all 3 wonder bwolfes - 3 t2 adv
5 '13 store pets - 5 early '09 rares
13 '14 store pets - 13 early to mid '09 rares
15 '15 store pets - 15 mid to late '09 rares
23 '16 store pets - 23 late '09 to early '10 rares
25 '17 store pets - 25 early to mid '10 rares
10 '18 store pets - about 10 mixed '10 rares? or roughly 5 '08 vrs
rounding the store pets up to aproximately 91 mixed '09 rares
t5 adv + 13 t2 adv = 54-67 Mixed 09 Rares
you're looking at about 145-158 mixed '09 rares worth on your side

the first trade would need to double their offer in my opinion, but of course, it all depends on how you personally value the pets

now assuming your side is the same
the second trade has
1 Black Advent - t13 sept (joHN FITZGERALD KENNEDY IT'S THAT HIGH IN DEMAND NOW??? IM SO OUT OF IT)
1 rerelease ('09 or '10 i forget which) zodiac dog and those are valued super weird so excuse my math for considering them a plain '09
1 grey malk dragon - t12 sept
t13 + t12 + 1 '09 = (54-70 mixed '09 rares) + (49-62 mixed '09 rares) + 1 '09 = 104-133 mixed '09 rares

this is a much better offer! i assume you can get more than one '09 out of a zodiac but don't @ me

to make a long story short, i'll take the middle ratings of all of them

yours: about 152 mixed '09 rares worth aka 21 mid adv + low adv aka (main t6)pink/blue balloon + low adv

offer one: about 70 mixed '09 rares worth aka 10 mid advents aka (sept t10)Blue Rose + (sept t4) scarf pps roughly

offer two: about 119 mixed '09 rares aka 17 mid advents aka 2 (sept t10) blue roses + (sept t4) scarf pps aka (main t1) red X pps + (sept t10) BLue Rose aka somewhere between a (m t3) skeleton pps and a (m t4) ur purple horse??? i think it's closer to the main tier 4 but my head hurts
longest story short, i wouldn't accept either of these personally but the second trade with the BA and Malk dragon is closest though still overpay on your side

/;-;/ i swear i spent an hour trying to figure this out good grief

[lexa.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78217884&userid=843624&signature=xpjrYhPlDgnzYJR4WQJ-IQ
Is this fair?

[Kzadrin]

Is this fair?
Im terrible at knowing what items are worth

I think it's underpay for the items. Items are generally valued as a common/uncommon of the same year. I'm not really sure what year the flurfle is from, but it seems fairly recent.

The flurffle is from 2016. Someone just told me one advent pet is going for a whole blanket set. Is a whole set going for 1 pet?
Any advice on how to make it seem more fair if it's not?

[Skull.Vincent]

Need some advice on this trade.

They're offering BEG + Strawberry for my Dogtag, but is the strawberry going for that much right now? How much is the BEG going for?

Thank you for any help!

[WeirdWhiteStarDoggo]

alright i need a bit of external assistance
i've not dealt with zebras myself before, christmas or not

what opinions do you have of this trade? for an auction of mine
here

and i was just offered this for yellowfang what do you warrior traders think of this demand wise? personally i don't exactly like it but even so is the offer fair demand wise? what should i be looking for in the future?

h elp

[nvsebleed]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78160851&userid=566222&signature=zj_WylbZ5PwFX_JSdze-1g

Haven’t been online for a while so I’m not sure

unfair to you. their uncommon pet and c$ don't add up to the worth of your pets

[grimalkin_grins]

this? x
I know the sheepdog has 2 very rare outcomes and 2 rare outcomes, so I'm not sure how likely either outcome is.

[Skull.Vincent]

Need some advice on this trade.

They're offering BEG + Strawberry for my Dogtag, but is the strawberry going for that much right now? How much is the BEG going for?

Thank you for any help!

[Kzadrin]

Is this fair?
Im terrible at knowing what items are worth

The flurffle is from 2016. Someone just told me one advent pet is going for a whole blanket set. Is a whole set going for 1 pet?
Any advice on how to make it seem more fair if it's not?