The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[~Phantom]

2008 non-list VR = new store pet set.

Is this fair? If not, what needs to be added, where?
Thank you

The new store pets are worth roughly a late 2010 rare.
If a 2008 non-list VR is worth roughly four '09 rares, therefore, 8 '10 rares?
The store pet side must add four '10 rares
My maths may be a tad wrong. However, it is very unfair for the VR'08 side

[kaiserbakura]

How much difference is there between a PPS malik Dragon and a Spotted Tribal? I need to know if this is fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78031440&userid=901965&signature=z2M_tn_UKVaxttim4EUKvA

[spencer]

How much difference is there between a PPS malik Dragon and a Spotted Tribal? I need to know if this is fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78031440&userid=901965&signature=z2M_tn_UKVaxttim4EUKvA

That's very unfair to you since the Spotted Tribal is right below the Big Gap and higher on the list than the PPS dragon which is at the bottom of the list actually.

[Alina]

may i get some opinions on this trade?
I really love the quantity but I am unsure what the cucumbers go for.
(I value the joker and bengal at a non each)

[triple decker bus]

so I have 2 carousel horses and I just found out that they've just become advent tier 2 lists and i think they are worth 4-5 '09 rares each?
here's the trade
i tried calculating hh so
i think all the store pets add up to about one of the horses and the extra rares add up to about a 2011 rare + around a 2012 rare or something (my brain can't count)? but I'm not really sure about the rat (+usually lower demand for rats)
i think i'll keep the horses but i thought of getting some opinions so is this fair/would you accept this?
sorry this is really long

[Demonking Urizen]

2008 non-list VR = new store pet set.

Is this fair? If not, what needs to be added, where?
Thank you

The new store pets are worth roughly a late 2010 rare.
If a 2008 non-list VR is worth roughly four '09 rares, therefore, 8 '10 rares?
The store pet side must add four '10 rares
My maths may be a tad wrong. However, it is very unfair for the VR'08 side

One more opinion, maybe? Thank you!

[Constellation.]

2008 non-list VR = new store pet set.

Is this fair? If not, what needs to be added, where?
Thank you

The new store pets are worth roughly a late 2010 rare.
If a 2008 non-list VR is worth roughly four '09 rares, therefore, 8 '10 rares?
The store pet side must add four '10 rares
My maths may be a tad wrong. However, it is very unfair for the VR'08 side

One more opinion, maybe? Thank you!

From what I know most people value an '08 rare at an '09 + '10 rare. So
'08 VR = 2 '08 rares
2 '08 rares = 2 '09 rares + 2 '10 rares
2 '09 rares + 2 ' 10 rares = 4 '10 rares + 2 '10 rares = 6 '10 rares.
The new store pet set is worth 4 late '10 rares, so it would be unfair to the '08 VR by 2 '10 rares, or an '09 rare. (:

[Necrøzma]

Is this Fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78046868&userid=819660&signature=BuIHN9eKB-Quu6qXVs9UzQ
Thank you in advance!

[knifemew]

Is this Fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78046868&userid=819660&signature=BuIHN9eKB-Quu6qXVs9UzQ
Thank you in advance!

They have to change some newer rares for 1 or 2 old rares

[the]

Is this Fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78046868&userid=819660&signature=BuIHN9eKB-Quu6qXVs9UzQ
Thank you in advance!

They have to change some newer rares for 1 or 2 old rares

Please give only educated advice. The gap between the rose rat (3-4 rares '09) and hollyfox cat (6-7 rares '09) is 3-4 rares '09. Their side is worth almost 5, so they're slighty overpaying.