The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[☽isa☾]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77940686&userid=819898&signature=xAWw4Eb-_b3xSJIQjR27BA

is this fair? considering that it's a staff pet

[Aeriux]

I really need help with these trades!!!


Okay I got another offer, but I don't think any of the pets are list pets and I have another one for my Blue Balloon dog. I will list all the trades and I would like to know which one is more fair.
1
2- I know this one is unfair
3
☆those were list trades
Here are normal pet trades (common-very rare)
1
2
3
4
5
6

I apologize for all these trades and me asking about them. I'm still pretty new around here. I really appreciate all of your help!

fixed the links!

[sumatra.]

i'm pretty sure this is unfair to me, but i've not considered demand?


also these from before:

Anyone able to help me with these bids?
Thank you in advance <3

bid one
---------------
bid two
---------------
bid three
---------------
bid four
---------------
bid five
---------------
bid six
---------------
bid seven

Any help on these is appreciated.

First trade; neither have any more demand than the other so it is indeed unfair to you

Bid 1;
Using the 2:1 ratio their side is worth about 9 2009 rares while your side is only worth 1 2009 rare

Bid 2;
Worth about 2.5 2009 rares. Your side is worth 1 2009 rare

Bid 3;
Their side is worth 1 2009 rare + 2016 rare. Your side is worth 1 2009 rare

Bid 4;
Their side is worth 3 2009 rares, yours is worth 1 2009 rare

Bid 5;
Worth 2 2009 rares, your side is worth 1 2009 rare

Bid 6;
Their side is worth 1.5 2009 rares. Your side is worth 1 2009 rare

Bid 7;
Their side isn’t even worth 1 2009 rare.

[jellyfishl]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77948208&userid=790841&signature=Fn1Qh21o1INR2NbVlLYKZw

would you guys accept? is this fair? i need quick replies, thanks!

[LaCreatura]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77946926&userid=895269&signature=C32mzf6EDN9liOdd_7nvKw

If im not wrong this is unfair to the bottom, because a 2018 store pet ia worth a late 2010 rare (i think) but i dont think the pets theyadded would make it fair...
Correct me if im wrong

[sumatra.]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77946926&userid=895269&signature=C32mzf6EDN9liOdd_7nvKw

If im not wrong this is unfair to the bottom, because a 2018 store pet ia worth a late 2010 rare (i think) but i dont think the pets theyadded would make it fair...
Correct me if im wrong

2017 Store Pet= Mid 2010 Rare
2018 Store Pet = Late 2010 Rare

It is just slightly unfair to the bottom.

[DrinaLestrange]

Help? Involves store pets and 08 rare?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77870878&userid=293678&signature=dkxvdovvNNcrBgUNHWZt3Q

[NeonRosez]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77948460&userid=818914&signature=2zhu9MbJ4s_rLWLN5FyWaw

is this fair? c:

[Caslixe]

this?

[Aleigh]

how's this demand wise?

how about this one?