The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sumatra.]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77815581&userid=907285&signature=gxJUjOKUuapZE5F_TOsloQ

Unfair to them by rarity and demand. A 2010 rare is worth 4 2010 uncommons, at least. The Zodiac dogs have extra demand, so usually people require a lot more ^-^'

Actually there’s no set worth on how many uncommons equals a rare. Lots of users use the 4:1 ratio like you, but lots also use the 2:1 ratio.

The zodiac is only worth 1 2010 Rare. Demand is up to the user and their trading partner.

Not to mention 2018 store pets are worth a late 2010 Rare themselves.

Your side using the 2:1 ratio is worth 1 2009 Rare, which is overpay for the zodiac

[Sandstorm814]

Got this offer on my liontail - Is it worth it?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77815551&userid=806395&signature=PpQ9iT-p2lp7d5zcrVP39g

[AriaHayes]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77797376&userid=42103&signature=UXrxV_yIWKsrm8RsZagang

[c a b b a g e]

Can someone tell me if this is fair? When it comes to items and stuff I'm never sure. Thank you!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77816278&userid=307960&signature=tQT_EtV8nH7emeQsnV3D0Q

[Corey Taylor]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77814908&userid=781126&signature=h9XpJ1VFWl6qKKsLoMJh9w

How's this trade?

[protect]

x
is this fair under or over? and if so by how much

[Claire Cooper]

Okay so I found someone who was willing to accept this trade not a lot really responded or cared too look at it I guess, I don't know maybe there was something wrong I didn't see.

But can anyone tell me how fair or unfair this trade was?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77731359&userid=70359&signature=4IGnWmk8fBqeBxGee6ZCxw

[nat13]

May I please get some help on these two trades please?
1. x
2. x
Thanks a bunch! C:

[Eevee]

is this trade fair? Doesn’t the Valentine’s Day items go for a 09 rare each?

[knifemew]

is this trade fair?

i think you're over, maybe quit few items like 5-8