The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[CookieButterLatte]

Am I undertrading?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77696949&userid=889028&signature=iW5BMClMjtTn885pJs28hw

[Grottan]

Am I undertrading?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77696949&userid=889028&signature=iW5BMClMjtTn885pJs28hw

Yes. Due to demand AND rarity just the regular set of warrior cats can fetch ya a main list such as a green tox

Each warrior is worth 2x it's rarity value in demand, basically- If not more. Bluestar is very hard to find and can get an advent on it's own if you find the right person

(Im unsure about where that bun is?)

[Vexious]

Am I undertrading?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77696949&userid=889028&signature=iW5BMClMjtTn885pJs28hw

rarity wise this is unfair to them, demand wise it is all up to you and your partner.
edited !

[Targaryen]

I don't plan on keeping any of the pets offered in a trade - they'll be traded.
Can I have opinions on what trades are better? I named them the name of the pet of which the bulk value is assigned in the trade for my raven. What would you personally accept/why?

I value the raven at 1.5-2 nons,
Eat Me at 1 non,
Liontail @ 1 Sorb
Marionette @ 1 Sorb
UR Bwolf/Zebra @ <1 non

• Grapes
• Pot + quantity RL
• Spotted Tribal
• UR Fox
• Nontag
• UR Bwolf
• UR Cinnabun
• UR Aussie
• Eat me
• Zonkey

[Vexious]

@targaryen
I personally would ethier accept the ur butterfly wolf offer or the eat me offer.
since you are looking to trade the pets you get I know the ur butterfly wolf trade is massively over paying your 1.5-2 non value.
however how you and your partner take in demand is up to you both, it depends if youd like something worth more but may take longer to trade off or easy to trade off worth less then the ur butterfly wolf. i would take the eat me offer, but then again people are different.

[boston]

I don't plan on keeping any of the pets offered in a trade - they'll be traded.
Can I have opinions on what trades are better? I named them the name of the pet of which the bulk value is assigned in the trade for my raven. What would you personally accept/why?

I value the raven at 1.5-2 nons,
Eat Me at 1 non,
Liontail @ 1 Sorb
Marionette @ 1 Sorb
UR Bwolf/Zebra @ <1 non

• Grapes
• Pot + quantity RL
• Spotted Tribal
• UR Fox
• Nontag
• UR Bwolf
• UR Cinnabun
• UR Aussie
• Eat me
• Zonkey

The top 3 trades I would personally accept are the cinnamon bun, eat me and zonkey trade. The zonkey can easily fetch two nons and even after list placement i've been offered 2 nons for my cinnamon bun. For the eat me, they also have 2 other store lists included, which are just growing with demand which will make it easier for you to trade off.
Hope this helps!

[dakotapaws]

how fair is this?

WARNING: BULK

and this bid as well as this one?

this bid too? and this?

[lilpupin]

I need help before I send this trade, any given would be very appreciated!

So, I'm going to offer this: https://i.imgur.com/giZo0EM.png
for this: https://i.imgur.com/qyrKzQO.png

Is it fair?

This is very unfair to you!
You have to take the very rare from your side or add much more to their side
Also take off the 2013 rare from your side

Thank you very much!
Can anyone give me a second opinion, please? What should I do to make it better for me? Just get rid of the horse?

[Banana.]

How is this??
x
If I’m over, great! I’m having an awful time trading my grinner away haha

[mastergirl7]

could I please get some help with this?
I would really appreciate any advice on this trade, and if either of us needs to add anything. Thank you so much to anyone who helps! <3

It's been three days could I please get some help with this? <3