The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Carmenthecat]

Is this fair?

Not fair to you I believe. Due to the age gap between the rares. They filled that age gap in with most of their pets then asked for a ton more from you. They have to add to their side or take from your side

[sinpai]

Please help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77573619&userid=949591&signature=9ErTaOKUnb-t2kcKeKrycA

It's fair but if I were you I would wait till they got their rarity (the apple thing) to see if it will be a rare

even if it was rare it's unfair to the other side
They are overpaying

[Oblivion.]

Joker for UR CinnaBun?
What should be added to make it fair? And what is general demand for both them?
Thank you in advance

[FenFen]

Im trying to trade of my ur-bwolf I was told it was worth 3 nons and a sorb but its been a while so im trying to get 2 nons worth

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77573990&userid=267761&signature=b2ggS0JshnPt7RQQs3pemA
is that 2 nons worth of pets?

[recherché.]

I need help with this trade please? :)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77563558&userid=750162&signature=d2iTU_rwSsRUjNKU5cDyVw

- Leah

[Supreme]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574163&userid=702384&signature=a08W6O6qf6uMKgRb6Pd3-Q

[VIZCERABUN]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574290&userid=942355&signature=AJBzbUdlFngA-wzZAZSLTw


Is this fair? I have no idea what the rAtTo is worth-

[KkSpecial]

Are any of these trades fair??

1. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77571560&userid=410864&signature=y3dq4iS6JJ7uXV6vL6C4eA

2. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77540853&userid=410864&signature=pVjXzI8iM3VK_4PT-qXm8g

3. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77540864&userid=410864&signature=Zv9V3A2GUWX-tjWo6R7PxA

4. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77571554&userid=410864&signature=eAoN644lIycPjShkyn4jng

5. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77551194&userid=410864&signature=cLxEScLpKQzwiXGckB7jEw

6. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77572146&userid=410864&signature=qV0Kw4Lbk6CNxTICu90Sug

7. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77571630&userid=410864&signature=Fgi8749NZiw639NW-hfAeQ

8. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77572111&userid=410864&signature=MXci32hncQD_tKqeLSDkzA

Trade 01 -

Unfair to the top - rarity wise
Bottom adds up to 2 Sorbets + ~ 2.5 Mid Advents

Nick Unicorn = 2 Sorbets + 1 Red Rose (Red Rose = 5 Mid Advents)

2 Sorbets
Holly Fox = Tier 7 Advent (Mid Advent) = 7-8 2009 Rares
Flop Blood Dog = Tier 5 Advent (Mid Advent) 6-7 2009 Rares
Brown Red-String Horse = Tier 4 Advent (Low Advent) = 5-6 2009 Rares

Quantity has its own value to consider, as well
Demand is up to you and your trading partner


Trade 02 -

Fair - rarity wise
Demand is up to you and your trading partner

Spotted Tribal = 2 Sorbets

Trade 03 -

Unfair to the top - rarity wise
Demand is up to you and your trading partner

Spotted Tribal = 2 Sorbets

Trade 04 -

Unfair to the top - rarity wise
Demand is up to you and your trading partner
Bottom adds up to 2 Sorbets + ~ 2.5 Mid Advents

Rainbow Mane = 24 Mid Advents
Spotted Tribal = 2 Sorbets

2 Sorbets
Holly Fox = Tier 7 Advent (Mid Advent) = 7-8 2009 Rares
Flop Blood Dog = Tier 5 Advent (Mid Advent) 6-7 2009 Rares
Brown Red-String Horse = Tier 4 Advent (Low Advent) = 5-6 2009 Rares


Trade 05 -

Unfair to the top - rarity wise
Demand is up to you and your trading partner
Top side adds up to 7 2009 Rares

Jack 'O Lantern Rat = Tier 1 Advent = 3-4 2009 Rares

Trade 06 -

Unfair to the bottom - rarity wise
Demand is up to you and your trading partner
Quantity has its own value to consider, as well

Bottom side adds up to ~ 170.5 Mid Advents
Top side adds up to ~ 94 Mid Advents

Red Toxic = 63 Mid Advents
Rainbow Mane = 24 Mid Advents
20.5 2009 Rares = ~ 3 Mid Advents
200 C$ = ~ Pink Striped September Tier = 4 Mid Advents

2 Sorbets = 84 Mid Advents each = 168 Mid Advents
Holly Fox = Tier 7 Advent (Mid Advent) = 7-8 2009 Rares
Flop Blood Dog = Tier 5 Advent (Mid Advent) 6-7 2009 Rares
Brown Red-String Horse = Tier 4 Advent (Low Advent) = 5-6 2009 Rares

Trade 07 -

Fair - if you value the UR Peas at 2 Sorbets, if you value them at less then it is unfair to the bottom
UR Peas generally go for 1-2 Sorbets

The UR Peas are not currently placed on the list - but when placed will not be below the gap
Demand is up to you and your trading partner

Trade 08 -

Unfair to the top
The C$ alone is overpay
Flop Blood Dog = Tier 5 Advent = 75 C$

Demand is up to you and your trading partner

[Supreme]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574484&userid=702384&signature=2ZCdANGfcDeM6uKzwJUiZw FAIR??

[SarcasticLoner]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77566438&userid=381069&signature=szPcbN4hmLj-vlPZqftFSg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574612&userid=381069&signature=gyVkVVdkE4xn-JSYCRAv7A

Can I get opinions on these please? c: