The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Corinnander]

this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77129060&userid=681882&signature=Dggg-6qK1P7Kaqz9uxj6kw

I don't think so, solely because the demand for those Warrior acts makes them much more valuable. I'm not an expert on rarity, though.

[KkSpecial]

Would you guys have accepted this?

Personally, no - as the bottom was overpaying.
1 2017 Rare = 1 2015 Uncommon
The bottom side adds up to 1 2010 Uncommon + 1 2011 Uncommon.

Thanks! I copied the trade but it just said copied to clipboard??

Anyone else? I'll just say what it was: The banner eyeball dog, a rare 2014 cow, a rare jungle event pet, one of the current mask halloween BWs, and an uncommon parrot for a mid-late 2009 rare dog

Unfair to the Mid/Late 2009 Rare Dog.

The Banner Dog will be either a 2018 Uncommon or a 2018 Rare at most and even with the pets on the other side of the trade they do not add up to anywhere near a 2009 Rare - granted this is assuming the 2009 Rare Dog is just that and not a list pet worth more than that.

[bostonlobstah]

Thanks! I copied the trade but it just said copied to clipboard??

Anyone else? I'll just say what it was: The banner eyeball dog, a rare 2014 cow, a rare jungle event pet, one of the current mask halloween BWs, and an uncommon parrot for a mid-late 2009 rare dog

[list][size=90]Unfair to the Mid/Late 2009 Rare Dog.

The Banner Dog will be either a 2018 Uncommon or a 2018 Rare at most and even with the pets on the other side of the trade they do not add up to anywhere near a 2009 Rare - granted this is assuming the 2009 Rare Dog is just that and not a list pet worth more than that.

Thanks! I cancelled the trade, because I also didn't think the banner dogs would be perceived as so valuable!
It'll probably end up like the whole macaw hype--they end up being not so valuable after all.

[Kaminarii]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77158131&userid=857986&signature=58M4lEvtkV_w-cnOU-yNVA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77155336&userid=857986&signature=s0VlsrfgMXP_hQqW1WroCQ

wondering about the fairness of these two trades! <3

[/quote][/quote]

[SilverWoes]

Is this fair?

[The Plague.]

how does this look?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77137925&userid=736731&signature=HyP0uwoyYnXKz0VSdw0HuA

[Lopez]

sfnjfnekj
What needs to be added to make this fair?
Thanks in advance!

would we be able to get a 2nd opinion? My trade partner is worried that they're overtrading, and I want to make sure it's fair for them as well as us!

[QueenSiren]

I already accepted it on a bit of a whim, but I was wondering if this was fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77023732&userid=897504&signature=002TB2BPQDjXL_vDT432XA

[flora]

is this fair?

[knight.]

hii ! is this fair ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77093199&userid=948478&signature=KTDUJSOXckcZYz9VJmn8pQ
thanks for your help !!