The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SyrupBean]

Hello, would this trade be fair? Thank you. c:

[KkSpecial]

Is this a fair trade?

Unfair to the top side of the trade by the C$ alone - the pets are extra.

Mid 2010 Rare = 25-30 C$
Late 2010 Rare = 20-25 C$
2010 Uncommon = 6-9 C$ each
2018 Uncommon = Less than 1 C$

Total Bottom Side Worth: 66-85 C$

*The Unknown Rarity pets could potentially be at the most 2018 Rares or at the least 2018 Uncommons - worth 1-3 C$ or less than 1 C$ depending on how they turn out - they do not have a heavy effect on the trade.

- For the sake of the evaluation I valued all of the 2018 pets at 0.5 C$ each - basically all at the worth of an Uncommon -

*Note; Uncommons and below do not have a set C$ value - it is up to you and your trading partner on where you value them - the prices provided in the evaluation given above were taken from a rough guideline provided by the C$ Worth Thread

I've just been sent this trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77169210&userid=769655&signature=My-9rmUEMVMjFgE0iTZbQw
Is this fair? My first impression is it's not but I wanted to double check.

Unfair to the bottom side of the trade.

2016 Store Pet = 1 Early 2010 Rare

The top side only adds up to slightly over 1 2015 Rare.

how fair is this?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77159736&userid=736731&signature=6F--wUjcQEC8UoKQyCvGyg

UR Apple = 15 Mid Advents

Dark Leopard = 8.5 Mid Advents
July Lioness = 2 2012 Rares - with demand it seems to fetch 1 Low/Mid Advent

Rarity wise this is unfair to the UR Apple - demand is up to you and your trading partner.

Is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77169876&userid=897504&signature=ilZQixIMng8_DhdMGxbaOQ

Very unfair to the bottom side of the trade.

Dark Purple 2nd Gen Dog = 2008 Rare - extended into August 2009 = 1 Mid 2009 Rare
Dark Green Rave Dog = 1 Mid 2010 Rare

The top side only adds up to a little over 1 2016 Rare.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77170261

Is this fair??? They told me the eyeball is high demand...
But I would take the eyeball out of circulation anyways so not going to get anything from it....
Is the eyeball guy really that valuable?

Wrong link - use the share trade link at the bottom of the trade.

And no - at the moment the Eyeball Banner Dog has an inflated demand but at most will be a 2018 Uncommon/Rare after the event and the hype dies down, so will the demand with the Banner Dog (if you are referring to the Eyeball Banner Dog).

[Rbpuppy]

Does anyone know the demand on a Moonswirl? I’m currently working out a trade for one and I just want to know if they’re still popular (:

[Infectedcontent]

Trade
Unfair?

[Kitty&Cats]

Hello, would this trade be fair? Thank you. c:

I would personally take it because store pets have a lot more demand than those common-uncommon pets. Not very many people like to trade down. Hope I helped and feel free to get other advice!

[bostonlobstah]

How do you add a trade?? sorry

[sumatra.]

*Personally* would you take this?

[KkSpecial]

Hello, would this trade be fair? Thank you. c:

Unfair to the top - the bottom even with the quantity does not add up to a 2010 Rare.

2017 Store Pet = 1 Mid 2010 Rare

Does anyone know the demand on a Moonswirl? I’m currently working out a trade for one and I just want to know if they’re still popular (:

Rarity wise the Moonswirl Dog is worth 4 Nons - no one can give you an answer demand wise as it varies from player to player.
It is up to you and your trading partner on where you value the dog and the other pets involved in the trade.

You can find out what pets are worth here by using the search function

Trade
Unfair?

Unfair to the bottom - the top only adds up to slightly over 1 2015 Rare.
They need to add more to be worth the 2009 Rare on the bottom.

How do you add a trade?? sorry?

Answered in my previous post above.
Go to the bottom of the trade you want to share and copy the link at the bottom of the page.

[EmeryAmrik]

How do you add a trade?? sorry

I saw the trade before you took down the link, but from what I saw it was definitely not fair, the eye banner dog isn't going to make up that difference in rarity.

[The Plague.]

how does this look?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77137925&userid=736731&signature=HyP0uwoyYnXKz0VSdw0HuA