The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[flora]

Was this fair?

I took a long break from CS and totally forgot how much store pets are worth ;v;;

Very unfair to the store pet, as it is worth a 2010 rare. The bottom is only worth a 2014 rare + a little add.

[flora]

aaaa I value the sleipnir as a low september list, but is this worth it? ;n; I have no idea what the rose pps goes go normally

also reposting this, if me valuing the sleipnir as a low september is ridiculously high, please do correct me. ;n;

[christina30]

Need help with this trade please
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77071942&userid=915619&signature=OBS1GTfRQfaysjo6uSxaqw
Thank you

[Yak]

i'm really bad at juding item value but i know
that older items are more valuble and these
are pretty old so... is this fair?

[*Neechee*]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=77072974&userid=124240&signature=pR7QkfPgWuxklHLQ3Nwu3A thank you.

[Topiratti]

]are any of these fair?

for the august PPS lion i value you it at a mid to high advent, to a low september

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77069136&userid=10993&signature=Tn53Ko6GilGb38PMUMZb8A

not what the peach or zebra go for

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77067388&userid=10993&signature=hA72pnguz4GVeqqVwgXutg

not sure about this one

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77019067&userid=10993&signature=Y_M2sgeRNeeTAe9mtYR11Q

sldo got this, it seems unfair to me - note i vlure the beg and ur malk at a non each, does this total almost 3 nons worth? does it cover any of the pets?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77070200&userid=10993&signature=XfhIJ-V6m7NJnJudms2goQ

please do not reply if you are unsure or do not know the list please

thanks for time an help.

[flora]

Need help with this trade please
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77071942&userid=915619&signature=OBS1GTfRQfaysjo6uSxaqw
Thank you

That's a early 09 rare, I believe they range from 30-45 cs. The bottom has 6 tokens, and then 15 tokens worth of token trade in pets (21 tokens, if you value them at 2 cs each, = 42 cs.) But, if we assume the pets to be rare, there's no way they would equal an early 09 rare after the event. I think I'd personally accept.
(also, unsure what year the rat is from originally.)

[flora]

i'm really bad at juding item value but i know
that older items are more valuble and these
are pretty old so... is this fair?

I believe the floating rocks alone would be worth 2013 uncommon each, as they're from the dream event and are old. I think it's very unfair to the bottom.

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=77072974&userid=124240&signature=pR7QkfPgWuxklHLQ3Nwu3A thank you.

Also unfair to the bottom, as the items are all much older than the pets offered.

[flora]

i'm really bad at juding item value but i know
that older items are more valuble and these
are pretty old so... is this fair?

I believe the floating rocks alone would be worth 2013 uncommon each, as they're from the dream event and are old. I think it's very unfair to the bottom.

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=77072974&userid=124240&signature=pR7QkfPgWuxklHLQ3Nwu3A thank you.

Also unfair to the bottom, as the items are all much older than the pets offered.

this? and this?
please help. i’ve been asking for many pages now (:
-alura

For the second one, I believe it is unfair to the pet side as the eggs are normally only worth an uncommon from the same year. Only eggs 1-2 (or 1-4?) are worth greatly. here's the eggie guild! I cannot help much with your first trade however though, I'm sorry!

[roadkilll]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77055415&userid=926996&signature=dakurOFOjF5NoPKj68Xd1w

The butterfly wolf is from 2010 originally